Nature & Wildlife

Heidegger: Learning

This is the final draft of my entry on Heidegger for the Encyclopedia of Educational Philosophy and Theory, edited by Michael Peters.
of 10
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Related Documents
  Encyclopedia of Educational Philosophy and Theory, edited by Michael A. Peters.  Heidegger: Learning Eduardo Duarte,Hofstra University“What is lacking, then, is action, not thought….We must be ready andwilling to listen. !artin Heidegger, What is Called Thinking?  1 “"he hardest a##renticeshi# is that by which $#eo#le% learn how tohear and heed no im#erative other than that relation…&setting thehuman logos  in its #ro#er relation to the  Logos’ . 'einer (ch)rmann,  Heidegger On Being and Acting: From Principles to Anarch!  "  !artin Heidegger returned to the University of *reiburg in thewinter semester of +-+, and in the following summer of +- hedelivered his /nal lectures before his formal retirement from theuniversity. "hose lecture courses were organi0ed under the title Washeisst #enken?  , or the 1uestion $hat is called thinking? or what calls thinking2 3  4s 5. 6lenn 6ray reminds us in his introduction to the /rstEnglish edition of Heidegger7s lectures, these courses in +-+8+-“were also the /rst lectures he was #ermitted to give $in *reiburg% since +99, when he was drafted by the :a0is into the #eo#le7smilitia ; %olksst&rm < and was afterwards forbidden to teach by the*rench occu#ying #owers. 6ray adds that the interru#tion in histeaching must have been costly for Heidegger because “Heidegger isabove all else a teacher. 9  =t7s #roductive to listen to 6ray7s#ronouncement and allow it to guide us towards an understanding of what Heidegger tells us about learning in that last year of teaching at*reiburg.“Heidegger is  above all else a teacher 88 this is veri/ed by oneof his most renowned and devoted students, Hannah 4rendt, who,when asked by the  'e$ (ork )e*ie$ o+ Books  to write an essay tocommemorate Heidegger7s eightieth birthday, audaciously dated hisnativity as “ neither the date of his birth ;(e#tember >, +??, at!esskirch< nor the #ublication of his /rst book, but the /rst lecturecourses and seminars which he held as a mere  Pri*atdo,ent ;instructor< and assistant to Husserl at the University of *reiburg in++. -  4rendt continued@*or Heidegger7s “fame #redates by about eight years the#ublication of -ein &nd .eit ;  Being and Time < in +AB indeed it  is o#en to 1uestion whether the unusual success of this bookCnot ust the immediate im#act it had inside and outside theacademic world but also its etraordinarily lasting inFuence,with which few of the century7s #ublications can com#areCwould have been #ossible if it had not been #receded by theteacher7s re#utation among the students, in whose o#inion, atany rate, the book7s success merely con/rmed what they hadknown for many years."here was something strange about this early fame,stranger #erha#s than the fame of Gafka in the early "wentiesor of ra1ue and Iicasso in the #receding decade, who werealso unknown to what is commonly understood as the #ublic andnevertheless eerted an etraordinary inFuence. *or inHeidegger7s case there was nothing tangible on which his famecould have been based, nothing written, save for notes taken athis lectures which circulated among students everywhere. "heselectures dealt with tets that were generally familiarB theycontained no doctrine that could have been learned,re#roduced, and handed on. "here was hardly more than aname, but the name traveled all over 6ermany like the rumor of the hidden king.=t is indeed 1uite tem#ting in the s#ace of an encyclo#edia entryto take u# the #hiloso#hical history of Heidegger 1ua teacher, andthereby engage his thinking in relation to 4rendt and his other famousstudents whom (heldon Wolin called “Heidegger7s children. >  =f Heidegger is  above all else a teacher then it is 1uite reasonable totrace the educational force of his thinking in the out#ut of his #roli/cand inFuential students who, like 4rendt, Herbert !arcuse, and Hans 5onas, were among those who attended his lectures and seminars,es#ecially the earliest ones that #roduced the notes that circulatedlike bootlegged live #erformances. "oday, however, it is im#ossible to imagine the notes from theearly lecture courses retain the aura they once emanated when theywere circulated in 6ermany thirty8nine years before the hidden Gingwas dethroned from his #rofessor7s chair in *reiburg. =ndeed,im#ossible, because l’a/aire Heidegger    continues to generateincreasing infamy, most recently with the the J+- #ublications of Heidegger7s -ch$ar,e He+te , or “black notebooks, where, from +3+8 +AJs, Heidegger ke#t his own #rivate notes. :ot the early tradednotes, but, rather, the black notebooks is where it is claimed, today,that one encounters the lingering rumor of the hidden Ging, a rumorthat has now mor#hed into the rumor of what the Ging has hiddenbehind the closed doors of his study. Grell insists that Heidegger7s black notebooks can only be readas eem#lars of &nthinking  because there is almost nothing that is  genuinely thought8#rovoking in the thousands of #ages. A  What oneencounters in -ch$ar,e He+te  is generated from the mood of theegomaniacal, written by a fugitive from thinking. Ket it remains a1uestion how far removed these &#rivate7 words stand in contrast toHeidegger7s &#ublic7 teaching. 4nd this 1uestion is relevant to thosewho remain students of Heidegger7s #ublished writing that nowincludes the notorious black notebooks alongside the reveredmonogra#hs, lectures, dialogues, essays and #oems. =ndeed,engaging in a conversation with him, which is to say learning withhim, demands that we acknowledge the co8eistence of both thefamous and infamous /gures, the two “Heideggers@ the one /gurea##earing in the seminar room, who moves with his students into theclearing of thinking, and the other, remaining behind closed doors,working s&0 rosa . With the one we encounter the &Irivatdo0ent7 or&teacher,7 and with the other hand we encounter &Herr 'ektor7 or&administrator.7 "oday students of Heidegger who are moved by his thought8#rovoking writing are also familiar with the s&0 rosa  Heidegger, andwith the details that 6ray did not include in his +>? introduction to What is Called Thinking?   Heidegger was elected rector of *reiburgUniversity on 4#ril +, +33 ;three months after Hitler becamechancellor<. He became a member of the :a0i #arty on !ay +st, andremained one until +9-. 4nd during that twelve8year s#anHeidegger gave at least one well known lecture course titled“=ntroduction to !eta#hysics, where he notoriously #rofessed “theinner truth and greatness of :ational (ocialism. "his line remainedin the tet when it was #ublished in +-3, eactly one year after heoLered his /nal courses in #hiloso#hy at *reiburg. “Heidegger is  above all else a teacher. *rom the historicaldistance of time and #lace what we learn from l’a/aire Heidegger   canbe summoned u# in the title of a book by :iet0sche, who was thesubect of lecture course Heidegger oLered at *reiburg between+3>8+9J. ?  "he title of :iet0sche7s book is  H&man All too H&man . Ilaced within eistential force generated by this title, the twoHeideggers are, together, absolved by the higher truth revealed in thetragedy that constitutes a human life@ to be human, all too human, isto co8eist as sinner and saint. "he com#lete title of :iet0sche7s book bears a coincidentalrelation to the name of the city ;*reiburg aka *ree8city< whereHeidegger lived and taught@  H&man All too H&man: A Book +or Free-pirits . "he etended title suggests /rst and foremost the form of :iet0sche7s writing@ the a#horism. 4nd with that in mind the title,along with the form it evokes, we /nd an im#ortant fragment inHeidegger@ “the essence of truth is freedom. "he fragment, from theessay, “Mn the Essence of "ruth,   yields a word 1uestion thatstudents of Heidegger are re#eatedly confronted with@ “  +reedom?    =n +?A, the same year that Nictor *arias #ublished  Heidegger et le 'a,isme , the English edition of 'einer (ch)rmann7s  Heidegger:On Being and Acting  was #ublished. (ch)rmann7s thesis is thatHeidegger must be read from the end to the beginning ;i.e., studiedfrom his last dee#ly musical and #oetic writings and from there back to  Being and Time <. +J  4 fragment from (ch)rmann7s book directs us toe#and the title of Heidegger the &teacher7 as &teacherOlearner7. "hise#anded title enables us to gras# the #riority of learning toHeidegger7s later #roect, which, in eLect, will enable us to trace this#riority 0ack  to the beginning of his earliest work as a  Pri*atdo,ent .(ch)rmann writes@ “"he hardest a##renticeshi# is that by which$#eo#le% learn how to hear and heed no other im#erative than therelation…of human logos  in its #ro#er relation to the  Logos .  4n a##rentice is a novice, a beginner, but also a beginning. 4s 4rendt citing (t. 4ugustine once insisted, we can begin because weare a beginning@ “$the human #erson% is free because $they are% abeginning….ecause $they are % a beginning, $the human #erson% canbeginB to be human and to be free are one and the same. 6od created$humanity% in order to introduce into the world the faculty of beginning@ freedom. ++  =n this sense an a##rentice in theHeideggerian sense is not only a beginner in being a novice, but alsobeginning in being the a##earance of freedom in the world. Pearninghow to hear and heed  Logos  entails 0ecoming  a beginning. "helearner is the reali0ation of freedom in the world. Pearning undertaken by the a##rentice of  Logos  involves a techne  ; τεκνε < that is no mere technical techni1ue ;&how to7< but a poein ; ποειν < that res#onds to the fundamental 1uestion 2+reedom?     Poein ; ποειν < hears the 1uestion of freedom as the 1uestion of eing,and res#onds by making meaning. =n turn, the hardest a##renticeshi#is learning how to listen to human logos in relation to  Logos , andthereby receiving the call ;ins#iration< to make or com#ose ameaningful contribution to the world, which is to say, a work of art thegathers others into the clearing, or region of #eace. Pearning to listenis thus the #rocess of learning the techne  that most #ro#erly attains tohuman being@ dwelling. ““"he word for #eace,  Friede , means the free, das Fre …."o dwell, to be set at #eace, means to remain at #eacewithin the free. +  =n sum, res#onding to the call of  Logos , to the1uestion of freedom, entails undertaking the work that brings about#eace. “Heidegger is  above all else a teacher 88 and as one who#ursued the evasive dynamic of thinking he remains 0e+ore and 0eond  all others a learner. With regard to Heidegger in the contetof learning, what should interest us is what remains 0e+ore  and 0eond the personas  ;the masks #laced u#on him by himself and byothers, including his students #ast, #resent, and those who will comelater<. "o hear Heidegger the teacher is to listen8with Heidegger the  learner, which is to listen not  to Heidegger per se  but to  Logos . Whenwe do this the student recogni0es what remains 0e+ore  the /gures of &Heidegger,7 behind these masks, is the shared breath, the humans#irit, the (oul, which is ultimately ehaled through and moves 0eond  those masks. "hus what remains always before and  beyond isthe ins#iration ;the breath in8s#ired, s#irit< from  Logos , receivedthrough the fundamental 1uestion “  +reedom?3  and carried out inres#onse to the instruction to “make something meaningful, “make aworld of meaning, “make a meaningful world@ make, build,something lasting, something beautiful, something that will sublimatemortality, something worthy of remembering, of re#airing andrenewing. =n order to receive  Logos , and thus to be in8s#ired by the Word,the mask of &Heidegger7 must give way to the call that #recedes fromthe (#irit that is heard as the antepersona  of  Herr )ecktor  . Pearning#roceeds via listening, because human logos ;saying< is #receded by  Logos  ;universal calling<. +3  *or the later Heidegger, the one a studentmust begin with, removing the mask of #ower #roved to be the mostdiLicult challenge within “the hardest a##renticeshi#. 4s Grell #utsit, the fundamental 1uestions #ursued by Heidegger “What calls on usto think2...give &s #ause. Here we must assert less, listen more. +9 *or his #art, Heidegger recogni0ed the struggle with the mask of #ower in his /nal lectures, announcing from the onset that thefundamental task of the teacher is to be a learner, and within thecontet of a learning community, the  4rst  learner@"he teacher is ahead of his a##rentices in this alone, that he hasstill far more to learn than they 88 he has to learn to let themlearn. "he teacher must be ca#able of being more teachablethan the a##rentices. "he teacher is far less assured of hisground than those who learn are of theirs. =f the relationbetween teacher and taught is genuine, therefore, there is nevera #lace in it for the authority of the know8it8all or theauthoritative sway of the oLicial. =t is still an ealted matter,then, to become a teacher 88 which is something else entirelythan becoming a famous #rofessor.; WCT +-< "he move from assertion to listening involves a resolution torelin1uish willing, or to will non8willing, what Heidegger, following themedieval mystic theologian !eister Eckhart calls 5elassenheit ;releasement<. 'eleasement of the will is a sus#ension of the will8to8#ower, that desire to im#ose or #lace u#on oneself, others and theworld a sing&lare tant&m , a single world8view or system of belief ;dogma<. 5elassenheit , the releasement of the will, #laces one intolearning via unlearning, into the uncertainty that is confronted beyonddogma and the will8to8#ower@ “when we learn to think...we must allow
Related Search
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks

We need your sign to support Project to invent "SMART AND CONTROLLABLE REFLECTIVE BALLOONS" to cover the Sun and Save Our Earth.

More details...

Sign Now!

We are very appreciated for your Prompt Action!