A Turkish Effendi on Christendom and Islam

Blavatsky Pamphlets A Turkish Effendi on Christendom and Islam No. 8 A Turkish Effendi on Christendom and Islam by H.P. Blavatsky Reprinted from “Bla k!ood s Edin#ur$h %a$a&ine'( No. )CC*++I ,anuary -88. /ol C++/II 0ith a 1ore!ord Pu#lished #y The 2.P.B. *i#rary' Toronto'3n. Canada FORE OR! 4in e the *etter herein reprodu ed !as !ritten' nearly fifty years a$o' the onfli t #et!een the t!o ontendin$ reli$ious for es' Christianity and Islam' has #e ome not only more a ute' #ut more !orld5 !id
of 12
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Related Documents
  Blavatsky Pamphlets A Turkish Effendi on Christendom and IslamNo. 8 A Turkish Effendi on Christendom and Islam by H.P. Blavatsky Reprinted from “Blak!ood s Edin#ur$h %a$a&ine'(No. )CC*++I ,anuary -88 /ol C++/II0ith a 1ore!ordPu#lished #y The 2.P.B. *i#rary' Toronto'3n. Canada FOREOR! 4ine the *etter herein reprodued !as !ritten' nearly fifty years a$o' the onflit #et!een the t!o ontendin$ reli$ious fores' Christianity and Islam' has #eome not only more aute' #ut more !orld5!ide. Christianity' re$arded as a moral and ethial influene' is on its trial no! as never #efore in its lon$ and' it must #e admitted' #lood5stained history.The letter is an e6at reprint from the ,anuary num#er of Blackwood's Edinburgh   Magazine  for -88. It puts #efore the pu#li so admira#le a summin$5up of the attitude and vie!s of a ultured and intelli$ent %oslem' that it has seemed #oth timely and useful to inlude it in the Blavatsky Pamphlet series' to the end that the 0estern peoples may have the opportunity to study the real issue of the onflit' from the point of vie! of Islam. As the !riter speaks of his onnetion !ith the Theosophial movement founded #y 2. P. Blavatsky' it is pro#a#le that he is one of the Initiates !ho !ere kno!n to #e !orkin$ in the Near East at that time.The inditment !hih the !riter of the *etter #rin$s a$ainst Christianity is a heavy one. It has #een stated time and a$ain in one form or another 7 cf  . Blavatsky Pamphlet No. -. #y many !ho' !hile admirin$ profoundly the Christian ethial teachings ' fail to disover muh evidene of their atual  practice  #y those nations !hih nominally profess to hold and to follo! the reli$ion of its founder.The British 9overnment representative' to !hom the *etter !as $iven' e6plains in an introdutory note the irumstanes under !hih he met the mysterious !riter. I TRO!#CTOR$ OTE In the su#ur# of one of the most romantially situated to!ns in Asia %inor there lives the most remarka#le oriental !hom it has ever #een my fortune to meet. Travelin$ throu$h that interestin$ ountry a fe! months a$o' !ith the vie! of assistin$ the British 9overnment to introdue some muh needed Pa$e 1  Blavatsky Pamphlets A Turkish Effendi on Christendom and IslamNo. 8 reforms' I arrived at 5555555555555555. I purposely a#stain from mentionin$ the name of the plae' as my Eastern friend' to !hom I am inde#ted for the follo!in$ paper' desires his incognito  to #e o#served' for reasons !hih the reader !ill easily understand on its perusal. I remained there some !eeks e6aminin$ the state of the surroundin$ ountry' at that time a $ood deal distur#ed' and $ivin$ the loal authorities the #enefit of a little !holesome ounsel and advie' !hih' I need sarely say' they !holly disre$arded.:%y offiious interferene in their affairs not unnaturally proured me some notoriety; and I reeived' in onse<uene' numerous visits from mem#ers of all lasses of the ommunity detailin$ their $rievanes' and an6ious to kno! !hat hane there mi$ht #e of a fori#le intervention on the part of En$land #y !hih these should #e redressed. In my interourse !ith them' I !as struk #y their onstant allusion to an apparently mysterious individual' !ho evidently en=oyed a reputation for an almost supernatural sa$aity' and !hose name they never mentioned e6ept in terms of the $reatest reverene' and indeed' I mi$ht almost say' of a!e.:%y uriosity at last #eame e6ited' and I made speial in<uiries in re$ard to this unkno!n sa$e. I found that he lived a#out a mile and a half out of the to!n' on a farm !hih he had purhased a#out five years a$o; that no one kne! from !hene he had ome; that he spoke #oth Turkish and Ara#i as his native ton$ues; #ut that some supposed him to #e a 1rank' o!in$ to his entire ne$let of all the eremonial o#servanes of a $ood %oslem' and to a ertain forei$n mode of thou$ht; !hile others maintained that no man !ho had not #een #orn an oriental ould adapt himself so naturally to the domesti life of the East' and a<uire its soial ha#its !ith suh ease and perfetion. 2is erudition !as said to #e e6traordinary' and his life seemed passed in studyin$ the literature of many lan$ua$es > his a$ent' for the purhase and for!ardin$ of suh #ooks and papers as he needed' #ein$ a forei$n merhant at the nearest sea5port. 2e seemed possessed of onsidera#le !ealth' #ut his mode of life !as simple in the e6treme; and he employed lar$e sums in relievin$ the distress #y !hih he !as surrounded' and in protetin$ #y the neessary #ri#es those !ho !ere una#le to protet themselves from oppression. The result !as' that he !as adored #y the ountry people for miles round' !hile he !as rather respeted and feared than disliked #y the Turkish offiials > for he !as e6tremely tolerant of their finanial neessities' and <uite understood that they !ere ompelled to s<uee&e money out of the peasantry' #eause' as they reeived no pay' they !ould starve themselves unless they did.To this $entleman I sent my ard' !ith a note in 1renh' statin$ that I !as a travelin$ En$lishman' !ith a seat in the 2ouse of Commons in immediate prospet at the omin$ eletion' onsumed !ith a desire to reform Asia %inor' or at all events' to enli$hten my ountrymen as to ho! it should #e done. Perhaps I am !ron$ in sayin$ that I atually put all this in my note' #ut it !as ouhed in the usual tone of mem#ers of Parliament' !ho are rammin$ politial <uestions a#road !hih are likely to ome up ne6t session. I kno! the style' #eause I have #een in the 2ouse myself. The note I reeived in reply !as in En$lish' and ran as follo!s?)EAR 4IR >If you are not other!ise en$a$ed' it !ill $ive me $reat pleasure if you !ill do me the honour of dinin$ !ith me to5morro! evenin$ at seven. I trust you !ill e6use the preliminary formality of a visit' #ut I have an appointment at some distane in the ountry' !hih !ill detain me until too late an hour to all. Pa$e 2  Blavatsky Pamphlets A Turkish Effendi on Christendom and IslamNo. 8 Believe me' yours very truly'.....................Effendi.:P.4. > As you may have some diffiulty in findin$ your !ay' my servant !ill #e !ith you at half5past si6 to serve as a $uide:.:)ear me:' I thou$ht' as I read this ivili&ed epistle !ith ama&ement' :I !onder !hether he e6pets me to dress:; for I need sarely say I had ome utterly unprovided for any suh ontin$eny' my !earin$ apparel' out of re$ard for my #a$$a$e5mule' havin$ #een limited to the smallest allo!ane onsistent !ith leanliness. Puntually at the hour named' my dra$oman informed me that ................... Effendi@s servant !as in attendane; and' arrayed in the shootin$5oat' knee5#reehes' and ridin$5#oots' !hih formed my only ostume' I follo!ed him on foot throu$h the narro! !indin$ streets of the to!n' until !e emer$ed into its $ardens' and follo!in$ a harmin$ path #et!een orhards of fruit5trees' $radually reahed its e6treme outskirts' !hen it turned into a narro! $len' do!n !hih foamed a #ra!lin$ torrent.:A steep asent for a#out ten minutes #rou$ht us to a lar$e $ate in a !all. This !as immediately opened #y a porter !ho lived in a lod$e outside' and I found myself in $rounds that !ere half park' half flo!er5$arden' in the enter of !hih' on a terrae ommandin$ a ma$nifient vie!' stood the house of my host .......a Turkish mansion !ith pro=etin$ lattied !indo!s' and a ourtyard !ith a olonnade round it and a fountain in the middle. A #road fli$ht of steps led to the prinipal entrane' and at the top of it stood a tall fi$ure in the flo!in$ Turkish ostume of fifty years a$o' no!' alas #eomin$ very rare amon$ the upper lasses. I !ondered !hether this ould #e the !riter of the invitation to dinner; #ut my dou#ts !ere speedily solved #y the empressement   !ith !hih this tur#aned individual' !ho seemed a man of a#out fifty years of a$e' desended the steps' and !ith the most onsummate ease and $rae of manner' advaned to shake hands and $ive me a !elome of unaffeted ordiality.:2e spoke En$lish !ith the $reatest flueny' thou$h !ith a sli$ht aent' and in appearane !as of the fair type not ommonly seen in Turkey; the eyes dark5#lue' mild in repose' #ut' !hen animated' e6pandin$ and flashin$ !ith the #rilliany of the intelli$ene !hih lay #ehind them. The #eard !as silky and sli$htly au#urn. The !hole e6pression of the fae !as ine6pressi#ly !innin$ and attrative' and I instintively felt that if it only depended upon me' !e should soon #eome fast friends. 4uh in fat proved to #e the ase. 0e had a perfet little dinner' ooked in Turkish style' #ut served in European fashion; and after!ards talked so far into the ni$ht' that my host !ould not hear of my returnin$' and put me in a #ed5room as niely furnished as if it had #een in a ountry5house in En$land.Ne6t mornin$ I found that my dra$oman and #a$$a$e had all #een transferred from the house of the family !ith !hom I had #een lod$in$ in to!n' and I !as politely $iven to understand that I !as fori#ly taken possession of durin$ the remainder of my stay at ............ > . At the e6piration of a !eek I !as so muh struk #y the entirely novel vie!' as it seemed to me' !hih my host took of the onflit #et!een Christendom and Islam' and #y the philosophi aspet under !hih he presented the Eastern uestion $enerally' that I asked him !hether he !ould o#=et to puttin$ his ideas in !ritin$' and allo!in$ me to pu#lish them > prefain$ his remarks #y any e6planation in re$ard to his o!n personality' !hih he mi$ht feel disposed to $ive. 2e !as e6tremely relutant to omply !ith this re<uest' his native modesty and shrinkin$ from notoriety of any sort presentin$ an almost insurmounta#le o#stale to his rushin$ into print' even in the stritest incognito . 2o!ever' #y dint of persistent importunity' I at last sueeded in #reakin$ throu$h his reserve' and he onsented to thro! into the form of a personal ommuniation Pa$e 3  Blavatsky Pamphlets A Turkish Effendi on Christendom and IslamNo. 8 addressed to me !hatever he had to say' and to allo! me to make any use of it I liked.I onfess that !hen I ame to read his letter' I !as some!hat taken a#ak #y the unompromisin$ manner in !hih the Effendi had stated his ase; and I should have asked him to modify the lan$ua$e in !hih he had ouhed his vie!s' #ut I felt onvined that' had I done so' he !ould have !ithdra!n it alto$ether. I !as' moreover' ashamed to admit that I dou#ted !hether I should find a ma$a&ine in En$land !ith suffiient oura$e to pu#lish it. As althou$h my friend !rote En$lish !ith e6traordinary faility for an oriental' the style !as some!hat defetive' I ventured to propose that I should re!rite it' retainin$ not merely the ideas' #ut the e6pressions as far as possi#le. To this he readily onsented; and as I read it over to him after!ards' and he approved of' it in its present form' I an $uarantee that his theory as to the ori$in and nature of the ollision #et!een the East and the 0est is aurately represented. I need not say that I differ from it' entirely' and in our numerous onversations $ave my reasons for doin$ so.:I !ill not enter into them here' ho!ever' as they !ill at one our to the intelli$ent reader; #ut not!ithstandin$ the many fallaies ontained in the Effendi@s line of ar$ument' I have thou$ht it !ell that it should' if possi#le' #e made pu#li in En$land' for many reasons.In the first plae' the <uestion of reform' espeially in Asiati Turkey' oupies a dominant position in En$lish politis; and it is of $reat importane that !e should kno!' not only that many intelli$ent Turks onsider a reform of the 9overnment hopeless' #ut to !hat auses they attri#ute the present derepit and orrupt ondition of the empire. 0e an $ather from the vie!s here e6pressed' thou$h stated in a most unomplimentary manner' !hy many of the most enli$htened %oslems' !hile lamentin$ the vies !hih have #rou$ht their ountry to ruin' refuse to o5operate in an attempt' on the part of the 0estern Po!ers' !hih' in their opinion' !ould only #e $oin$ from #ad to !orse. 2o!ever muh !e may differ from those !hom !e !ish to #enefit' it !ould #e folly to shut our ears to their opinions in re$ard to ourselves or our reli$ion' simply #eause they are distasteful to us. 0e an #est ahieve our end #y andidly listenin$ to !hat they may have to say.  And this must #e my apolo$y' as !ell as that of the ma$a&ine in !hih it appears' for the pu#liation of a letter so hostile in tone to our herished onvitions and #eliefs. At the same time' I annot dis$uise from myself that' !hile many of its statements are pre=udied and hi$hly oloured' others are not alto$ether devoid of some foundation in truth? it never an do us any harm to see ourselves sometimes as others see us. The tendeny of mankind' and perhaps espeially of En$lishmen' is so very muh that of the ostrih' !hih is satisfied to keep its head in the sand and see nothin$ that is distur#in$ to its self5omplaeny' that a little rou$h handlin$ oasionally does no harm.These onsiderations have indued me to do my #est to make :the #ark of the distant Effendi: #e heard' to use the fine ima$ery of Bon 9aultier; 4ay' is it the $lane of the hau$hty vi&ier' 3r the #ark of the distant Effendi' you fear(  — Eastern 4erenade?(Bon 9aultier s “Book of Ballads.(Pa$e 4
Related Search
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks