Essays

(2019) Is legal cognitivism a case of bullshit?

Description
(2019) Is legal cognitivism a case of bullshit?
Categories
Published
of 27
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Share
Transcript
  ! !"#$% '( )*+,- ./+012131(4 , .,(* /5 67--(8129 #$%&'( )* +'(,-./ 01234, 5 ': '02;/<7=21/0   678. '9 &:. ;'/& /,-3.8& 9.,&<(./ '9 '<( %<-&<(. 3/ &:,& &:.(. 3/ /' ;<%: =<--/:3&>? #,((@ A* B(,8C9<(& /&,&.D 38 :3/ E('F'%,&3F. ,8D '(3438,- .//,@ !" $%&&'()*  * !  #,F384 8'& C8'G8 &:,& &:3/ /.8&.8%. G,/ G(3&&.8 ;'(. &:,8 &:3(&@ @.,(/ ,4'? H  G. ;34:& :,F. &:'<4:& 3& ,&&.;E&.D &' D.E3%& &:. %<-&<(. '9 %<((.8& /'%3.&3./* I:. (3/. '9 E'E<-3/; 38 E'-3&3%/? &:. D3/&'(&3'8 '9 %';;<83%,&3'8 &:('<4: &:. </. '9 /'%3,- ;.D3,? ,8D '&:.( E:.8';.8, ,-3C.? :,F. =''/&.D &:. J<,8&3&@ '9 =<--/:3& &:,& 4'./ ,('<8D '( ,& -.,/& &:.@ :,F. ;,D. 3& /&(3C384-@ ;'(. F3/3=-.*   K8 &:. -.4,- /E:.(.? E,(& '9 &:3/ %<-&<(. 38%-<D./ , ;38'(3&@ &:./3/ 38 ,%%'(D,8%. G3&: G:3%: -.4,- D3/E<&./ %,8 =. /'-F.D 38 -34:& '9 , (34:& ,8/G.(* I:3/ &:./3/ 3/ :34:-@ %'<8&.(38&<3&3F.* L.4,- /@/&.;/ ;,@ :,F. 4,E/? /';. (<-./ ,(. 38D.&.(;38,&. '( ;,@ %'--3D. G3&: '&:.( (<-./ '(  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 B(,8C9<(& PHVVW? E* !Q* H   !" $%&&'()*   G,/ '(3438,--@ E<=-3/:.D 38 &:. +(, -./)*." -,0),1  38 !XYZ ,8D? &:.8? 38%-<D.D 38 B(,8C9<(&>/ %'--.%&3'8 '9 .//,@/ +(, 2345/*."6, 57 8(.* 8, 9./, :;5%*   38 !XYY* B38,--@? !" $%&&'()*   ,%:3.F.D &:. =./&/.--.( /&,&</ G:.8 [(38%.&'8 \83F.(/3&@ [(.// E<=-3/:.D 3& 38 &:. 9'(;,& '9 , D3;38<&3F. =''C 38 HVVW* #.(.,9&.( K G3-- (.9.( &' &:3/ -,&&.( .D3&3'8*  H G:3%: (.-3./ '8 &:. 3D., '9 &:. (<-. '9 -,G* I:.8? PK]Q &:. J<./&3'8 &:,& &3&-./ &:3/ E,E.( G3-- =. &,%C-.D* I:. 938,- /.%&3'8 P]Q G3-- '99.( , /<;;,(@ '9 &:. ,(4<;.8&*   '': >0 67--(812   ^:.8 B(,8C9<(& G('&. :3/ .//,@  < :. /<44./&.D &:,& &:. &'E3% :,D 8'& ,&&(,%&.D /<=/&,8&3F. (./.,(%:? /' &:,& &:.(. G,/ 8' &:.'(@ ,F,3-,=-. G:'/. /<=_.%& G.(. &:. %'8%.E& '9 =<--/:3&* `   a'G,D,@/? =@ %'8&(,/&? /<%: , &:.'(@ :,/ =..8 .-,='(,&.D ,8D B(,8C9<(& ;,@ G.-- =. D..;.D ,/ 3&/ 9'<8D.(* b  c.&? &:.(. ,(. /&3-- /';. 'E.8 J<./&3'8/ (.4,(D384 3&/ E('E.( %'8%.E&<,-3T,&3'8* I:3/ /.%&3'8 ,3;/ &' &,%C-. /';. '9 &:.;* B3(/&? K /:,-- 38&('D<%. B(,8C9<(&>/ %'8%.E&3'8 '9 =<--/:3& P)Q* d.%'8D-@? /';. %-,(393%,&3'8/ G3-- =. E(./.8&.D PRQ* L,/&-@? K /:,-- D.9.8D , E,(&3%<-,( F.(/3'8 '9 B(,8C9<(&>/ ;'D.- PeQ*   #: $;,0?57;2@( 10<155*;*0=*A2/A2;728 4/<*-   R<--/:3& 3/ , ;3/(.E(./.8&,&3'8? '( /' 3& 3/ ,(4<.D* R@ =<--/:3&&384? , /E.,C.( &(3./ &' 4.& ,G,@ G3&: G:,& /:. /,@/* W  I:.(. ,(.? :'G.F.(? ;<-&3E-. 9'(;/ '9 ;3/(.E(./.8&,&3'8* L@384? 9'( 38/&,8%.? /..;/ &' =. , D399.(.8& G,@ '9 4.&&384 ,G,@ G3&: G:,& '8. /,@/* I:.8? 39 G. ,3; &' 4.& , =.&&.( 4(3E '9 =<--/:3&? G. 8..D &' 38&('D<%. /';. /E.%393%,&3'8/*   ) E(';3/384 ,-&.(8,&3F. 3/ .M,;38384 &:. '=_.%& '9 &:. ;3/(.E(./.8&,&3'8? 3*.* G:,& 3/ ;3/(.E(./.8&.D G:.8 /';.'8. =<--/:3&/* B(,8C9<(& E('F3D./ &:. 9'--'G384 .M,;E-.N [ 3/ <8D.(4'384 , E,389<- %'8D3&3'8 ,8D &.--/ ^ &:,& /:. 9..-/ 6-3C. , D'4 &:,& :,/ =..8 (<8 'F.(>* ^ =3&&.(-@ (.E-3./N 6c'< D'8>& C8'G G:,& , D'4 &:,& :,/ =..8 (<8 'F.( 9..-/ -3C.>* Z  ) 93(/& (.,D384 '9 ^>/ %';E-,38& /<44./&/ &:,& ^ &:38C/ [ 3/ &=)">  ? &:,& 3/ &' /,@? :. &:38C/ `  B(,8C9<(& PHVVW? E* !Q* b  d.. e,(/'8 PHV!V? EE* WYfZ`Qg B,--3/ ,8D d&'CC. PHV!hQg +3/,C PHVVYQg 7-//'8 PHVVYQg #,(D%,/&-. ,8D i.3/%: PHVVZQg R'(;,8 PHV!!Q* W  B(,8C9<(& PHVVW? E* WZQ* Z  I:. .M,;E-. %'((./E'8D/ &' ,8 ,8.%D'&. '8 L<DG34 ^3&&4.8/&.38 (.%,--.D =@ B,83, [,/%,-N B(,8C9<(& PHVVW?  E* HbQ*  ` /:. D'./ 8'& 9..- 6-3C. , D'4 &:,& :,/ =..8 (<8 'F.(j* a'8.&:.-.//? ^ D'./ 8'& ,3; &' %(3&3%3T. &:3/ ,-&.(8,&3F.* #. D'./ 8'& &:38C &:,& [ 3/ ;3/(.E(./.8&384 :.( E,389<- %'8D3&3'8g (,&:.(? :3/ %'8%.(8 3/ E(3'( &' &:. /%(<&38@ '9 [>/ (.,- 9..-384/* h  ) /.%'8D (.,D384 %'8/3/&/ 38 ,(4<384 &:,& ^ %';E-,38/ =.%,</. [>/ /&,&.;.8& 3/ "5"',"',? I:.8? G. /:'<-D =. ,=-. &' &(,%. '<& , (.-,&3'8/:3E =.&G..8 8'8/.8/. ,8D ;3/(.E(./.8&,&3'8* ^:,& 3/ &:3/ (.-,&3'8/:3EO B'( 38/&,8%.? 3& ;34:& =. /,3D &:,& &,-C384 ,='<& /';.&:384 G3&:'<& :,F384 @"51&,A>,  ,='<& 3& %'8/&3&<&./ ,8 38/&,8%. '9 8'8/.8/.* )%%'(D384-@? [ G'<-D =. ;3/(.E(./.8&384 &:. C8'G-.D4. /:. :,/ 38/';<%: ,/ /:. D'./ 8'& C8'G :'G , (<8S'F.( D'4 9..-/g :.8%.? :.( /.8&.8%. 3/ 8'8/.8/.* ^. %,8 4' , /&.E 9<(&:.( =@ ,/C384 9'( &:. (.,/'8/ 9'( ,  E.(/'8 &' /E.,C ,='<& /';.&:384 /:. D'./ 8'& C8'G* )& -.,/&? &G' E'//3=3-3&3./ ,(. ,F,3-,=-.* 78 &:. '8. :,8D? [ %'<-D =. %".1./,  '9 G:,& /:. 3/ /,@384* B(,8C9<(& (._.%&/ &:3/ ,-&.(8,&3F.* K8 :3/ F3.G? [ (.,--@ <8D.(/&,8D/ :.( /&,&.;.8&? .F.8 ,& , ;383;<; -.F.- '9 <8D.(/&,8D384 &:,& &:. D'4>/ 9..-384 3/ , =,D 9..-384* Y  ^:,& (,&:.( D3/&<(=/ ^? B(,8C9<(& &:38C/? 3/ &:. D.4(.. '9 /E.%393%3&@ '9 [>/ /&,&.;.8&k3*.* &:. 9..-384 '9 , (<8S'F.( D'4* [>/ /&,&.;.8& 3/ 8'8/.8/.  =.%,</. /:. )' "5* 65"6,/",A 1)*( *(, */%*( * X  6#.( /&,&.;.8&>? ,/ B(,8C9<(& E'38&/ '<&? 63/ 8'& 4.(;,8. &' &:. .8&.(E(3/. '9 D./%(3=384 (.,-3&@>* !V  [<& D399.(.8&-@N [ 3/ ;3/(.E(./.8&384 &:. &@E. '9 .8&.(E(3/. /:. 3/ %';;3&&.D &'* B(,8C9<(& =.-3.F./ &:,& &:3/ 3/ &:. &@E. '9 ;3/(.E(./.8&,&3'8 &:,& D.938./ =<--/:3&* )/ , (./<-&? 3& %,8 =. /,3D? ^ %';E-,38/ =.%,</. [ G,/ =<--/:3&&384* K8 =(3.9? 38 ,%%'(D G3&: B(,8C9<(&>/ ,%%'<8&? =<--/:3& 3/ , ;3/(.E(./.8&,&3'8 '9 &:. .8&.(E(3/. '9 D./%(3=384 &:. (.,-3&@ G:3%: 3/ .ME(.//.D 38 , /E.,C.(>/ 38D399.(.8%.S&'S&(<&:* K /:,-- -,=.- &:3/ F3.G &:. 638D399.(.8%.S&'S&(<&: ;'D.-> '9 =<--/:3&* I:3/ ;'D.- G3-- =. &:. /&,(&384 E'38& '9 '<( ,8,-@/3/* #'G.F.(? ,/ E(.F3'</-@ ,88'<8%.D? &:. 8.M& /<=/.%&3'8/ G3-- /-34:&-@ D.F3,&. 9('; 3&*   6: 67--(812 ,0< B*-1*5(   h  B(,8C9<(& PHVVW? EE* Hh9Q* Y  B(,8C9<(& PHVVW? EE* HY9Q* X  B(,8C9<(& PHVVW? E* `VQ* !V  B(,8C9<(& PHVVW? E* `VQ*  b I:. 38D399.(.8%.S&'S&(<&: ;'D.- '9 =<--/:3& 3/ ,%&3F3&@S%.8&.(.D? !!  &:,& 3/ &' /,@? 3& ,--<D./ &' /E.%393% ;.8&,- /&,&./ '9 , /E.,C.(* I:3/ ;'D.- ;</& =. D3/&384<3/:.D 9('; ,8 '<&E<&S%.8&.(.D ;'D.-   ? !H  G:3%: T.('/ 38 '8 &:. %:,(,%&.(3/&3%/ '9 , /&,&.;.8&? /<%: ,/ 3&/ <8%-,(3&@ '( (<==3/:8.//* !`   #.(. K (./&(,38 ;@/.-9 &' .M,;38. &:. 9'(;.(*   ^:,& ,(. &:. /E.%393% E('E.(&3./ '9 &:. 38D399.(.8%.S&'S&(<&: ;'D.- B%.  ,%&3F3&@S%.8&.(.D ;'D.-O   e'8/3D.( &:. ,//.(&3'8 '9 E* 78. '9 &:. ;.8&,- /&,&./ '9 /E.,C.( M (.4,(D384 E 3/ , =.-3.9* K8  E,(&3%<-,(? M   ;,@ =.-3.F. &:,& E 3/ .3&:.( &(<. '( 9,-/.* K9 G. &,C. 9'( 4(,8&.D &:,& &:. &(<&:SF,-<. '9 E 3/ =.-3.9S38D.E.8D.8&? G. %,8 D399.(.8&3,&. &:. 9'--'G384 /3&<,&3'8/N !b   d ! N M =.-3.F./ &:,& E 3/ &(<.? ,8D E 3/ &(<.*   d HN M =.-3.F./ &:,& E 3/ &(<.? =<& E 3/ 9,-/.*   d `N M =.-3.F./ &:,& E 3/ 9,-/.? =<& E 3/ &(<.* d bN M =.-3.F./ &:,& E 3/ 9,-/.? ,8D E 3/ 9,-/.* !W   78%. B(,8C9<(&>/ %'8%.E&3'8 '9 =<--/:3& 3/ &,C.8 38&' %'8/3D.(,&3'8? &:./. E'//3=3-3&3./ ,(. &' =. .ME,8D.D* B'( , /E.,C.( %,8 ,-/' =. )"A)77,/,"*   (.4,(D384 &:. &(<&:SF,-<. '9 E* e'8/.J<.8&-@? '<( <83F.(/. '9 E'//3=3-3&3./ ;</& 38%-<D.N   d W N M =.-3.F./ 8.3&:.( &:,& E 3/ &(<. 8'( 9,-/. ,8D E 3/ &(<.*   d Z N M =.-3.F./ 8.3&:.( &:,& E 3/ &(<. 8'( 9,-/. ,8D E   3/ 9,-/.* )D,E&384 B(,8C9<(&>/ 8';.8%-,&<(.? G. ;,@ /,@ &:,& G:.(.,/ d ! Sd b  (.E(./.8& %,/./ '9 A,7,/,"6, S&'S&(<&:? /' &' /E.,C? d W S d Z  (.E(./.8& %,/./ '9 38D399.(.8%.S&'S&(<&:* !Z   !!  B(,8C9<(& PHVVH? E* `bVQ* d.. ,-/' i.3/%: PHVVZ? E* bHQ PD.9.8D384 &:,& &:. D3/&38%&3F. ;,(C '9 =<--/:3& 3/ 6.//.8&3,--@ E(,4;,&3%>Q* ^:.&:.( &:.(. ,(. ,%&3F3&@S%.8&.(.D ;'D.-/ D399.(.8& 9('; &:. 38D399.(.8%.S&'S&(<&: ;'D.- 3/ , J<./&3'8 &:,& :.(. G3-- (.;,38 'E.8* !H  B(,8C9<(& PHVVH? E* `bVQ* m. ^,,- -,=.-/ &:./. ;'D.-/ &:. 638&.8&3'8,-3/& /%:''-> ,8D &:. 6/&(<%&<(,-3/& /%:''->? (./E.%&3F.-@N ^,,- PHVVZ? E* !VVQ* !`  d.. e':.8 PHVVH? EE* ``!f``WQ* !b  B'( &:. /,C. '9 /3;E-3%3&@? K E(./.8& &:. E'//3=3-3&3./ 38 , =38,(@ 9'(;? =<& &:.@ ;34:& ,-/' =. E(./.8&.D ,/ 6=.-3.F384 &:,& E 3/ 8'& &(<.> ,8D 6=.-3.F384 &:,& E 3/ 8'& &(<.>? G:.(. &:. -,&&.( D'./ 8'& .8&,3- 6=.-3.F384 &:,& E 3/ 9,-/.>* !W  K& 3/ 8'&.G'(&:@ &:,&? ,%%'(D384 &' /&,8D,(D /E..%: ,%& &:.'(@? d `  ,8D d b  ,(. 6-384<3/&3%,--@ <8,%%.E&,=-.> 9('; ,  7)/'*C4,/'5"  E.(/E.%&3F.* ) %';E.&.8& /E.,C.( %,88'& /,@ 6K /&,&. &:,& E =<& K D' 8'& =.-3.F. &:,& E>N d.,(-. P!XhZ?  E* bQ* #.(.? :'G.F.(? G. ,(. ,D'E&384 , *()/AC4,/'5"  E.(/E.%&3F.* !Z  d.. ^,,- PHVVZ? EE* !Vh9Q PD3/%,(D384 %(.,&3'83/; ,/ , %,/. '9 =<--/:3& =.%,</. 3&/ /<=/%(3=.(/ 64.8<38.-@ =.-3.F. &:,& &:. &:.'(@ '9 .F'-<&3'8 3/ G('84>* 6nIo:. %(.,&3'83/&>? :. E38E'38&/? 6%,(./ ,='<& :'G &:384/ (.,--@ ,(.>Q*  W )& 93(/& /34:&? &:3/ (.%'8/&(<%&3'8 /..;/ 9,3&:9<- &' B(,8C9<(&>/ 38D399.(.8%.S&'S&(<&: ;'D.-* #. /<44./&/? 9'( .M,;E-.? &:,& 6&:.   .//.8%. '9 =<--/:3& 3/ 8'& &:,& 3& 3/  7.&',  =<& &:,& 3& 3/    4(5"= *> !h  L.& </ 9'%</ '8 &:. 93(/& E,(& '9 &:. /.8&.8%.* )/ B(,8C9<(& ,(4<./? 6,-&:'<4: n=<--/:3&o 3/  E('D<%.D G3&:'<& %'8%.(8 G3&: &:. &(<&:? 3& 8..D 8'& =. 9,-/.>* !Y  I:</? '8. ;34:& %'8%-<D.? &:. ;.;=.(/:3E %(3&.(3'8 9'( &:. =<--/:3&&.(/> %-<= 3/ 8'& E-,%.D 38 &:. %'-<;8 '9 &:. &(<&:SF,-<./ '9 /&,&.;.8&/? =<& 38 &:,& '9 =<--/:3&&.(>/ =.-3.9/* B<(&:.(;'(.? 38 D./%(3=384 &:. %';;'8,-3&3./  =.&G..8 =<--/:3&&384 ,8D &:. C38D '9 -384<3/&3% ,%&/ 9'<8D 38 , 6=<-- /.//3'8>? !X  B(,8C9<(& /&,&./ &:,& ='&: (.9.( &' -384<3/&3% 38&.(,%&3'8/ G:.(. E,(&3%3E,8&/ ,(. 8'& %';;3&&.D &' .ME(.//384 6G:,& &:.@ (.,--@ ;,&),0,  '( :'G &:.@ (.,--@ 9..->* HV  B'( &:. /,C. '9 , -,=.-? -.& ;. &.(; &:3/ ,%%'<8& ,/ &:. 6=.-3.9S=,/.D ,%%'<8&> '9 &:. 38D399.(.8%.S&'S&(<&: ;'D.-*   K8 ;@ 'E383'8? &:3/ ,%%'<8& D3/E-,@/ &:(.. D.93%3.8%3./* I' =.438 G3&:? 9('; /,@384 &:,&  =<--/:3& 3/ <8(.-,&.D &' &:. &(<&:SF,-<./ '9 , /&,&.;.8& D'./ 8'& 9'--'G &:,& 3& 3/ D.938.D =@ &:. /E.,C.(>/ =.-3.9/* A(,8&.D? &:3/ 3/ 8'& , %'8%-</3F. '=_.%&3'8? 9'( 3& _</& %'8&.8D/ &:,& =<--/:3& 3.=  =. =,/.D <E'8 /E.,C.(>/ =.-3.9/k8'& 8.%.//,(3-@? &:'<4:* B<(&:.(;'(.? /';. E,//,4./ '9 B(,8C9<(&>/ G'(C 43F. &:. 3D., &:,& :. 3/ ,(4<384 ,4,38/& &:3/ ,%%'<8&* B'( .M,;E-.? :. %'8&.8D/ &:,& 6nGo:,& =<--/:3& .//.8&3,--@ ;3/(.E(./.8&/ 3/ 8.3&:.( &:. /&,&. '9 ,99,3(/ &' G:3%: 3& (.9.(/ "5/ *(, ;,&),7' 57 *(, '4,.@,/ 65"6,/")"> *(.* '*.*, 57 .77.)/'D  * H!  d3;3-,(-@? :. /<44./&/ &:,&N 6n&o:. =<--/:3&&.( ;,@ 8'& D.%.3F. </? '( .F.8 38&.8D &' D' /'? .3&:.( ,='<& &:. 9,%&/ '( .;5%* 1(.* (, *.@,' *(, 7.6*' *5 ;, >* HH  K8 &:3/ /.8/.? , =<--/:3&&.( G'<-D 8'& =. D.938.D =@ &.--384 '( 8'& &.--384 &:. &(<&:k3*.* =.-3.F384 &:,& G:,& /:. ,//.(&/ 3/ .3&:.( &(<. '( 9,-/.k? =<& (,&:.( =@ , D399.(.8& ,&&3&<D. '( ;.8&,- /&,&.* L,/& =<& 8'& &:. -.,/&? ,%%'(D384 &' &:. =.-3.9S=,/.D ,%%'<8&? &:. %'(. '9 =<--/:3& 3/ &:. -,%C '9 /E.,C.(>/ =.-3.9/ ,/ &' , E('E'/3&3'8 &:,& :,/ =..8 ,//.(&.D Pd W S d Z Q* R<--/:3& ,/ 68'& %,(384 ,='<& &(<&:> %'8/3/&/ 38 =.-3.F384 8.3&:.( &:,& E 3/ &(<. 8'( 9,-/.* I:.8? &:.(. G'<-D =. ,8 !h  B(,8C9<(& PHVVW? E* bhQ* !Y  B(,8C9<(& PHVVW? EE* bh9Q* !X  K8 , =<-- /.//3'8? E.'E-. &,-C ,='<& E.(/'8,- ,8D .;'&3'8S-,D.8 ,/E.%&/ '9 -39.? &./&384 :'G &:.@ 9..- ,8D :'G &:. '&:.(/ (.,%& &' G:,& &:.@ &.8&,&3F.-@ /,@N B(,8C9<(& PHVVW? EE* `W9Q* HV  B(,8C9<(& PHVVW? E* `ZQ P.;E:,/3/ ,DD.DQ* B'( &:. %,/. '9 , =<-- /.//3'8? B(,8C9<(&/ /&,&./ &:,& .,%: E,(&3%3E,8& (.-3./ '8 6, 4.8.(,- (.%'483&3'8 &:,& G:,& :. .ME(.//./ '( /,@/ 3/ 8'& &' =. <8D.(/&''D ,/ =.384 G:,& :. p ;,&),0,' <8.J<3F'%,--@ &' =. &(<.>* B(,8C9<(& PHVVW? E* `hQ P.;E:,/3/ ,DD.DQ* H!  B(,8C9<(& PHVVW? E* W`Q P.;E:,/3/ ,DD.DQ* HH  B(,8C9<(& PHVVW? E* WbQ P.;E:,/3/ ,DD.DQ*
Search
Tags
Related Search
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks
SAVE OUR EARTH

We need your sign to support Project to invent "SMART AND CONTROLLABLE REFLECTIVE BALLOONS" to cover the Sun and Save Our Earth.

More details...

Sign Now!

We are very appreciated for your Prompt Action!

x