Documents

Cannabis Memorandum of Law

Description
Cannabis Memorandum of Law
Categories
Published
of 28
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Related Documents
Share
Transcript
  MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF PETITION FOR RULE MAKING OR ACTION Minnesota Board of Pharma! # $ Uni%ersit! A%en&e SE' S&ite ()* Minnea+o,is' MN ((-.-/) (. Memorandum in support of petition for rule making and action: Cannabis does not meet the statutory requirement of a Schedule I substance under Minnesota Statutes. K&rtis 0anna 1Petitioner2 s&3mits this Memorand&m in s&++ort of his Petition for R&,e Ma4in5 or Ation' &rrent,! 3efore the Minnesota Board of Pharma! 1the 6Board62' .2 to en5a5e in r&,e/ma4in5 to e7em+t +,ants of the 5en&s anna3is 1referred to as 8mari9&ana: in some MN Stat&tes and R&,es2 andmateria,s nat&ra,,! ori5inatin5 from them' in,&din5 tetrah!droanna3ino, 1T0C2 and anna3idio, 1CBD2 from Shed&,e I of Minnesota R&,es' 2 to in,&de in their t;o man&a, ann&a, re+orts to the Minnesota ,e5is,at&re the fat that anna3is is im+ro+er,! ,assified and )2 to +ass &+on the %a,idit! of the Minnesota R&,es < =#**>- .* 1C21.?2 and < =#**>- .* 1C21 (2 if the! deide not to en5a5e in r&,e/ma4in5 to e7em+t them from the ,ist of Shed&,e I s&3stanes in Minnesota R&,es>It is im+ortant to 3e ,ear a3o&t ;hat is 3ein5 so&5ht 3! this Petition and ;hat is not> First' remo%in5 anna3is and materia,s nat&ra,,! ori5inatin5 from them 1hereafter 8anna3is2 from Shed&,e I from Minnesota R&,es' as +etitioned herein' ;i,, not res&,t in the immediate aess to media, anna3is 3! media, +atients in Minnesota> Rather' remo%a, ;i,, 5reat,! inrease the hanes that Minnesota +atients ;i,, 3e a3,e to offer an affirmati%e defense in Minnesota Co&rts ;hen the! are in fat +ossessin5 anna3is for mediina, reasons> Remo%a, from the R&,es 3! the Board and s&3se@&ent remo%a, from the Stat&tes 3! the Le5is,at&re ;i,, restore rationa,it! to Minnesotas ,a;s' 3! remo%in5 o%ert onf,its that &rrent,! e7ist ;ithin them that e7ist d&e to Minnesotas +assin5 of C0APTER )..   S>F> No> -?* and the state ,a;s of )) other states> Additiona,,!' ;hen Minnesota forma,,! remo%es anna3is from Shed&,e I in 3oth the R&,es and Stat&tes d&e to the fat that it has a 8&rrent,! ae+ted media, &se in the United States:' Minnesota ;i,, then 3e standin5 on a +ro+er fo&ndation to administrati%e,! +etition the DEA to remo%e anna3is from Shed&,e I from the Federa, Contro,,ed S&3stanes At in a %er! simi,ar ;a! as the Petitioner is &rrent,! +etitionin5 the Board> S&h a +etition;o&,d ,i4e,! 3e s&essf&, d&e to the fat that the Federa, 1CSA2 simi,ar,! &rrent,! ,assifies anna3is as a Shed&,e I s&3stanes and defines Shed&,e I ;ith the e7at same ,an5&a5e> hi,e )- states in the United States ha%e no; +assed ,a;s sa!in5 that anna3is is a mediine' none ha%e remo%ed anna3is from their States %ersion of the Uniform Contro,,ed S&3stanes At ;ith the rationa, that anna3is has a 8&rrent,! ae+ted media, &se in the United States:> In fat' on,! a %er! ,imited n&m3er of states ha%e remo%ed anna3is from Shed&,e I at a,,> D&e to the fat that Minnesota' from the o&tset' has 3een %er! de,i3erati%e in their a++roah to +assin5 a media, anna3is ,a;' it is the d&t! of the Board of Pharma! to dea, s@&are,! ;ith the +arts of the ,a; &nder their +&r%ie; that ;ere o%er,oo4ed om+,ete,! d&rin5 this de,i3erati%e +roess> S&h an ation 3! the Board ;o&,d ,i4e,! res&,tin +rotetin5 Minnesota +atients' state em+,o!ees' +harmaists' dotors' man&fat&rin5 om+anies' their em+,o!ees' and man! more Minnesota itiens from the threat of the federa, 5o%ernments interferene as this +ro5ram mo%es for;ard> To i5nore the im+at that this ,a;' and the ,a;s of )) otherstates' has had on the Minnesota Contro,,ed S&3stanes At ;o&,d 3e irrationa, and re4,ess> Indeed' no; is the +erfet time to ;ei5h in on this matter> The Board has 3efore it the a3i,it! to initiate the r&,e/ma4in5 +roess to remo%e anna3is from Shed&,e I of the Minnesota R&,es and deide to reommend  to the ,e5is,at&re that the! remo%e anna3is from the Minnesota Stat&tes 3efore a sin5,e state/s+onsoredanna3is seed is +,anted on the 5ro&nd' 3efore a sin5,e +harmaist dis+enses it' and 3efore a sin5,e Minnesota +atient o3tains it> Petitioners see4 to fo,,o; the o&rse harted 3! the Minnesota Le5is,at&re ;hen it enated Minnesotas %ersion of the Uniform CSA> B! ;or4in5 ;ith the e7istin5 CSA str&t&re and +roed&res for remo%in5 or re,assif!in5 dr&5s from Shed&,e I' ;e an +ro%ide a hea,th! a,ternati%e to the methods of the otherstates ;ith media, anna3is ,a;s 3! reso,%in5 inonsistent ,a;s in Minnesota and +ro%idin5 a +ath for;ard to reso,%in5 the onf,it 3et;een state and federa, ,a;s on the to+i of media, anna3is> Ke%in Riah' in The Minnesota State Bars offiia, +&3,iation' Benh  Bar' had this to sa!Media, mari9&ana has arri%ed in Minnesota' and ,on5/s&fferin5 +atients ma! fina,,! find re,ief> Last month' stron5 3i+artisan ma9orities in the Minnesota 0o&se and Senate ,e5a,ied the &se of media, mari9&ana> Des+ite ;ides+read s&++ort for the ne; ,a;' ho;e%er' its s&ess is no s&re thin5>The man&fat&re' distri3&tion' and &se of media, mari9&ana remain federa, rimes e%en tho&5h Minnesota no; +ermits s&h ond&t> B&sinesses' 3an4s' dotors' +atients' and e%en ,a;!ers ris4 federa, +rose&tion for the sa,e and &se of media, mari9&ana' des+ite Minnesotasne; ,a;> F&rther' Minnesotas R&,es of Professiona, Cond&t +rohi3it a ,a;!er from o&nse,in5 a ,ient to en5a5e in a rime or assistin5 a ,ient en5a5ed in a rime> A ,a;!er ;ho +ro%ides 3asi 3&siness ad%ie or ,e5a, ser%ies to a mari9&ana/re,ated 3&siness' s&h as draftin5 or+orate formation or transationa, do&ments' ma! %io,ate not on,! federa, ,a; 3&t a,so Minnesotas ethis r&,es> Fina,,!' federa, 3an4in5 ,a; hamstrin5s those finania, instit&tions ,oo4in5 to in%est in or ser%e Minnesotas ne; media, mari9&ana 3&sinesses>Minnesotas media, mari9&ana 3&sinesses annot f&ntion' ,et a,one meet the needs of Minnesota +atients' ;itho&t the +rofessiona, ser%ies of ,a;!ers and 3an4s> Het the threat of federa, +rose&tion and other santion is a serio&s disinenti%e for +rofessiona,s to 5et in%o,%ed in the media, mari9&ana ind&str!> The ne; ,a;s s&ess ;i,, t&rn in ,ar5e +art on ho; Minnesotas U>S> Attorne!' the Offie of La;!ers Professiona, Res+onsi3i,it!' the Minnesota S&+reme Co&rt' and Con5ress reso,%e these ontraditions>htt+mn3enh3ar>om *.-*=hi5h/ho+esThe Minnesota Board of Pharma! has the ethia, and stat&tor! d&t! to at to he,+ reso,%e these ontraditions and has the +o;er to do so> Evidence in Support of Rulemaking: Cannabis as Currently !ccepted Medical se in the nited States. It is a matter of reord that a 5ro;in5 n&m3er of state 5o%ernments ha%e' ;ith inreasin5 fre@&en! in the +ast deade' reo5nied that anna3is has s&3stantia, %a,&e in mediina, a++,iations 3! enatin5 ,a;s or re5&,ations a&thoriin5 s&h &se> A +er&sa, of these %ario&s state re5&,ator! shemes a,so demonstrates that' as a +rod&t of de3ate and de,i3eration 3! 5o%ernment a5enies' hea,thare +rofessiona,s and onerned and affeted +atients' these states ha%e a,so esta3,ished ae+ta3,e safet! standards for the &se of anna3is &nder media, s&+er%ision> The +assa5e and e7istene of these ,a;s' in,&din5 Minnesotas o;n media, anna3is ,a;' s@&are,! and &ndenia3,! s&++ort the remo%a, of anna3is from Shed&,e .>  The fo,,o;in5 state stat&tes or re5&,ations +ro%ide 5enera,,! for the derimina,ied &se of anna3is &nder state ,a; 3! @&a,ified +atients &nder media, s&+er%ision and onditions A,as4a Stat&tes < .?>)? 1.$$#2J Ariona Re%ised Stat&tes' Tit,e )=' Cha+ter #>.' << )=/ #*. thro&5h )=/ #.$ 1 *.*2J Ca,ifornia 0ea,th  Safet! Code < ..)= >( 1.$$=2J Co,orado Constit&tion Arti,e III' Setion .- 1 ***2J Conneti&t P&3,i At No> . /((' Conneti&t Genera, Stat&tes' Cha+ter - *f 1 *. 2J De,a;are Code' Tit,e .=' Cha+ter -$A' << -$*.A thro&5h -$ =A 1 *..2J 0a;aii Re%ised Stat&tes < ) $/. . 1 ***2J I,,inois P&3,i At $#/*. 1 *.)2J Maine Re%ised Stat&tes < )#)/B 1.$$$2J Annotated Code of Mar!,and Setion .)))*. thro&5h .)))*) and .)))*? thro&5h .))).. 1 *.-2J Massah&setts Cha+ter )=$ of the Ats of *. 1 *. 2J Mihi5an Com+i,ed La;s' Cha+ter )))' << )))> =- . thro&5h )))> =-)* 1 **#2J Minnesota SF -?* // Si5ned into ,a; 3! Go%> Mar4 Da!ton on Ma! $' *.-' A++ro%ed B! Senate -=/.=' 3! 0o&se #$/-*' Effeti%e Ma! )*' *.-J Montana Code Annotated < (*/-=/.*. 1 **-2J Ne%ada Constit&tion Arti,e - < )# / Ne%ada Re%ised Stat&tes Annotated < -()A>*.* 1 ***2J Ne; 0am+shire Re%ised Stat&tes Annotated Cha+ter . =/ 1 *.)2J Ne; erse! P&3,i La;s **$' Cha+ter )*?' Ne; erse! Stat&tes' Cha+ter -=I' << -=./. thro&5h -=I/.= 1 *.*2J Ne; Me7io Stat&tes Annotated < )*/).C/. 1 **?2J Ore5on Re%ised Stat&tes < -?(>)** 1.$$#2J Rhode Is,and Genera, La;s < ./ #>=/. 1 **=2J .# ermont Stat&tes Annotated < --?. 1 **-2J Re%ised Code ashin5ton 1ARC2 < =$>(.A>**( 1.$$#2> D>C> La; .#/ .*J D>C> Offiia, Code' Tit,e ?' Cha+ter .=B' << ?/.=?.>*. thro&5h ?/.=?.>.) 1 *.*2> Additiona,,!' the fo,,o;in5 state stat&tes or re5&,ations +ro%ide 5enera,,! for the derimina,ied &se of 8,o; T0C' hi5h anna3idio, 1CBD2: +rod&tsA,a3ama' Senate Bi,, .?-' Si5ned into ,a; 3! Go%ernor Ro3ert Bent,e! 1A+r> .' *.-2J F,orida' Senate Bi,, .*)*' Si5ned into ,a; 3! Go%ernor Ri4 Sott 1&ne .=' *.-2J Io;a' Senate Fi,e )=*'Si5ned into ,a; 3! Go%ernor Terr! Branstad 1Ma! )*' *.-2J Kent&4!' Senate Bi,, . -' Si5ned into ,a; 3! Go%ernor Ste%e Beshear 1A+r> .*' *.-2J Mississi++i' 0o&se Bi,, . ).' Si5ned 3! Go%>Phi, Br!ant 1A+r> .?' *.-2J Misso&ri' 0o&se Bi,, )#' Si5ned 3! Go%> a! Ni7on 1&,! .-' *.-2JSo&th Caro,ina' Senate Bi,, .*)(' The 3i,, 3eame ,a; 3ea&se Go%ernor Ni44i 0a,e! did not si5n or %eto the 3i,, ;ithin fi%e da!s of its +assa5e 1Ma! $' *.-2J Tennessee' Senate Bi,, ().' Si5nedinto ,a; 3! Go%> Bi,, 0as,am 1Ma! .=' *.-2J Utah' 0o&se Bi,, .*(' Si5ned into ,a; 3! Go%ernor Gar! 0er3ert 1Mar> .' *.-2J isonsin' Assem3,! Bi,, ? =' Si5ned 3! Go%ernor Sott a,4er 1A+r> .=' *.-2>Gi%en the s&3stantia, 3od! of states reent,! a&thoriin5 anna3is for s&+er%ised media, treatments' it is sim+,! im+,a&si3,e to s&55est that there is 6no6 ae+ted media, &se for anna3is in the United States or that 6no6 safe,! ontro,,ed onditions ha%e 3een determined for s&h &se' as e%idened 3! media, anna3is re5&,ator!dis+ensar! +ro5rams that ha%e 3een de%e,o+ed in s&h states> In addition to these state ,a;s' the Petitioner +resents the fo,,o;in5 s&++,ementa, e%idene' e%en tho&5h it is 3e,ie%ed 3! the Petitioner that the on,! e%idene neessar! to sho; that anna3is doesnt 3e,on5 in Shed&,e I is one state media, anna3is ,a; and has +resented the Board ;ith )- of them>The U>S> De+artment of 0ea,th and 0&man Ser%ies +atent on the e7tration of nat&ra,,! o&rrin5 anna3inoids from mari9&ana for ,e5itimate media, +&r+oses> United State Patent No> ='=)*'(*? B.' Oto3er ?' **)> Canna3inoids as antio7idants and ne&ro+rotetantshtt+fi,es>io;amedia,mari9&ana>or5+etition *.*. .?dhhs **).**?>+df  In *.*' after a fo&r month ,on5 in%esti5ation' the Io;a Board of Pharma! reommended that anna3is 3e remo%ed from Shed&,e I of the Io;a Uniform Contro,,ed S&3stanes At> The! +ro+osed ,e5is,ation to transfer anna3is from Shed&,e I to II on No%em3er $' *.*htt+fi,es>io;amedia,mari9&ana>or5+etition *.*. .?i3+e *.** .?>+dfhtt+fi,es>io;amedia,mari9&ana>or5+etition *.*. .?ims *.**-.#>+dfhtt+fi,es>io;amedia,mari9&ana>or5+etition *.*. .?i3+e *.*.. ->+dfIn *.*' the Nationa, Assoiation of Boards of Pharma! a;arded the Io;a Board of Pharma! the Fred T> Mahaffe! A;ard for reommendin5 remo%a, of anna3is from Shed&,e I of the Io;a CSA> Thea;ard stated8After a n&m3er of +&3,i hearin5s' man! ho&rs s+ent ,istenin5 to +atients' dotors' +harmaists' and ,e5is,ators' as ;e,, as re%ie;in5 h&ndreds of media, arti,es and other state ,a;s' the Board mo%ed for;ard in its deision to reommend that the Io;a state ,e5is,at&re re,assif! anna3is as a Shed&,e II ontro,,ed s&3stane' ;hih ;o&,d a,,o; media, &ses of anna3is>: .*=th Ann&a, Meetin5' he,d Ma! / (' *.*' in Anaheim' CA> htt+fi,es>io;amedia,mari9&ana>or5+etition *.*. .?na3+ *.**( (>+dfMonda!' No%em3er ' *.*' the U>S> Dr&5 Enforement Administration +etitioned itse,f to +&t nat&ra,,! e7trated T0C in Shed&,e III 1;here s!ntheti T0C has 3een ,isted sine .$$$2J o,> ?( Federa, Re5ister' No> .*' +a5es =?*(-/=?*($' sho;in5 that the DEA no; onsiders anna3is to 3e a ,e5itimate so&re of FDA/a++ro%ed +harmae&tia,shtt+fi,es>io;amedia,mari9&ana>or5+etition *.*. .?dea *.*..*.>+dfThe e7istene of these a3o%e re5&,ator! shemes' the 5ro;in5 ae+tane of media, anna3is in the media, and sientifi omm&nit! e7em+,ified a3o%e' ;hen e7amined in ,i5ht of Minnesotas stat&tor! e7+,iit re@&irements for ,istin5 a dr&5 in Shed&,e I of the CSA' &n@&estiona3,! esta3,ish that anna3isno ,on5er @&a,ifies as a dr&5 that an 3e ,isted &nder Shed&,e I> Consistent ;ith the Boards mission ofre5&,atin5 the +ratie of dis+ensin5 of mediations in Minnesota' Petitioners res+etf&,,! s&3mit that the Board m&st remo%e anna3is from Shed&,e I> #revious petitions Petitioner has +re%io&s,! +etitioned the Board t;ie' on &,! )rd' *.* and Marh .=th' *..' to en5a5e in the r&,e/ma4in5 +roess to remo%e anna3is from the ,ist of s&3stanes ,assified as Shed&,eI in the Minnesota R&,es>On &,! )rd' *.* and Marh .=' *..' Petitioner fi,ed administrati%e +etitions for r&,e/ma4in5 ;ith the Board see4in5 the remo%a, of anna3is from the Minnesota R&,es> E,etroni o+ies of these t;o +etitions and the Boards res+onses ha%e 3een in,&ded ;ith the s&3mission of the &rrent Petition> Petitioner ar5&ed that the ,assifiation of anna3is &nder Minnesota Stat&te < .( >* 1 21)2 and Minnesota R&,es =#**>- .*1C21.?2 as ha%in5 8no ae+ted media, &se in treatment in the United States: 1Minnesota Stat&te < .( >* 1?21.22 ;as no ,on5er %a,id> 0anna ar5&ed that 3ea&se .- and .( states had ae+ted the media, &se of anna3is as of &,! )rd' *.* and Marh .=' *..' res+eti%e,!'anna3is had 8&rrent,! ae+ted media, &se in treatment in the United States:> 0anna ar5&ed the Board had a stat&tor! d&t! to initiate the r&,e ma4in5 +roess to remo%e anna3is from Shed&,e I 3ea&se it ;as 8&rrent,!: mis,assified as a matter of ,a;> 0e a,so ar5&ed that 3ea&se the ,e5is,at&re
Search
Tags
Related Search
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks