Documents

Disomangcop+v.+Datumanong

Description
Disomangcop+v.+Datumanong
Categories
Published
of 2
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Related Documents
Share
Transcript
  Disomangcop v. Datumanong (Tinga, 2004) 1 Facts: − On Aug. 1, 1989, RA 6734 was passed (Organic Act of ARMM). our pro!inces !oted for inc usion in ARMM, na#e $% &anao de 'ur, Maguindanao, 'u u and awiawi. − *n accordance wit+ it, O 4-6 was issued $ /res. 0or$ Auino on Oct. 1-, 1992. +e sa#ede!o !ed to t+e ARMM t+e power of t+e /5. − On Ma$ -2, 1999, O 119 was issued $ /5 'ec. igi ar. *t created a /5 Marawi 'uistrict ngineering Office w+ic+ s+a +a!e urisdiction o!er a nationa infrastructure proectsand faci ities under t+e /5 wit+in Marawi 0it$ and &anao de 'ur. − On an. 17, -221, RA 8999 w+ic+ created a new ngineering istrict in t+e first district of &anao de 'ur was passed $ /res. strada. − On Marc+ 31, -221, RA 924 w+ic+ a#ended RA 6734 was passed. +e pro!ince of :asi anand t+e 0it$ of Marawi !oted to oin ARMM t+roug+ said aw. − /etitioners iso#angcop and i#a otang in t+eir capacit$ as O*0 and nginer ** respecti!e $of t+e irst ngineering istrict of /5ARMM in &anao de 'ur fi ed a petition uestioningt+e constitutiona it$ and !a idit$ of O 119 and RA 8999 on t+e ground t+at t+e$ contra!enet+e constitution and t+e organic acts of t+e ARMM. Issue: WON DO 119 an ! #999 a$e %ot& inva'i an constitutiona'' ini$m.*e' an !atio:On ! #999 − RA 8999 ne!er eca#e operati!e and was superseded or repea ed $ a RA 924. :$ creatingan office wit+ pre!ious $ de!o !ed functions, RA 8999, in essence soug+t to a#end RA 6274,w+ic+ is an organic act w+ic+ eno$s affir#ation t+roug+ a p eiscite. 5ence, t+e pro!isionst+ereof cannot e a#ended $ an ordinar$ statute suc+ as RA 8999. +e a#endator$ aw needsto e su#itted a so to a p eiscite w+ic+ is ac;ing in t+e case of RA 8999. RA 6734 de!o !edt+e functions of t+e /5 to ARMM w+ic+ inc udes &anao de 'ur. − Moreo!er, RA 8999 is patent $ inconsistent wit+ RA 924 w+ic+ is a ater aw. RA 924, w+ic+is anc+ored on t+e 1987 0onstitution ad!ances t+e constitutiona grant of autono#$ $ detai ingt+e powers of t+e ARMM w+ic+ co!ers a#ong ot+ers &anao de 'ur. 5owe!er, RA 8999!entures to reesta is+t +e <ationa =o!ern#ent>s urisdiction o!er t+e infrastructure progra#sin &anao de 'ur. RA 8999 is patent $ inconsistent wit+ RA 924, and it destro$s t+e atter aw>soecti!e of de!o ution of t+e functions of /5 in ine wit+ t+e po ic$ of t+e 0onstitution togrant &=?s #eaningfu and aut+entic regiona autono#$. On DO 119+ O 119 creating t+e Marawi 'uistrict ngineering Office w+ic+ +as urisdiction o!er infrastructure proects wit+in Marawi 0it$ and &anao de 'ur is !io ati!e of t+e pro!isions of O 4-6w+ic+ i#p e#ents t+e transfer of contro and super!ision of t+e /5 to t+e ARMM in ine wit+ RA6734. +e office created under O 119 +a!ing essentia $ t+e sa#e powers wit+ t+e istrictngineering Office of &anao de 'ur as created under O 4-6, is a dup ication. +e O in effect ta;es ac; powers w+ic+ +a!e een pre!iou s$ de!o !ed under O 4-6. RA 924 +owe!er +as repea ed O 1Ange ica /ag icawan  119 ecause t+e for#er see;s to transfer contro and super!ision of /5 offices to ARMM.
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks