Documents

Sun Tzu and the Cost of War

Description
Millennial wisdom in the context of today's wars
Categories
Published
of 3
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Related Documents
Share
Transcript
  Sun Tzu and the Cost of War 4 October 2014 What if military strategy was timeless? Sun Tzu was a Chinese military general, strategist and philosopher, and is credited to have written “The Art of War”, a seminal treatise on managing conflict  and achieving victory in the battlefield. It is uncertain when he actually lived, but some traditional historians date his lifetime to 544  – 496 BC. The Art of War discusses strategy within the wider context of public administration, politics and planning. Organized in thirteen chapters, the text outlines theories of battle, but also advocates diplomacy and cultivating relationships with other nations as essential to the health of a state. For centuries, it has been regarded as the definite reading for military strategists, enthusiasts and warriors of all types. Sun Tzu’s work remains highly influential to this day . An internet search with his name produces over 10 million hits; in recent years there have been several best-selling translations and books applying the strategies to different fields, including negotiation, leadership and business. So influential in fact that certain authors claim China’s leaders follow a modern adaptation of his principles as they seek to transform their country into a world superpower in the 21 st  century. Exactly at a time when the Western Establishment seems to be very busy brushing them aside. Sun Tzu in Action Sun Tzu observed, analyzed and distilled what works and what doesn ’ t at war, and eventually developed an approach which transcended the battlefield. He emphasized the need to have a strategy planned well in advance of any campaign based on a detailed assessment of both adversaries ’  strengths and weaknesses: “If you know the enemy and know yourself you need not fear the results of a hundred battles.”  One particularly insightful observation is that open warfare should only be pursued as a last resort. In fact, Sun Tzu regarded winning without fighting as the pinnacle of military achievement. However, when there was no other choice, then the fighting should be as swift as possible: “There is no instance of a nation benefitting from prolonged warfare.”  That applies to the loser of course but also the victor, which is forced to expend substantial resources and in the end may not get much spoils to show for it, while becoming vulnerable to other attacks. Sun Tzu also warned us against relying too much on technological superiority: “Even the  finest sword plunged into salt water will eventually rust.”  Such superiority may win battles but not necessarily the war. And it is very costly. His principles remain relevant to this day not only because they were organized during a time of substantial human conflict in an advanced civilization, but they are deeply rooted in natural law. Even  the mighty lion chooses its prey carefully, aiming for the weakest of the bunch in the most economical way possible. The Cost of War Stephen Daggett, Specialist in Defense Policy and Budgets at the Congressional Research Service (considered to be the Congress’ think tank), authored a report in June 2010 outlining the cost of all the major wars the US has been involved in. His estimates, as well as a recent update on the cost of all the Post 9/11 wars by Professor Neta C. Crawford at Boston University, are presented in the following table: Major US War Period Cost(a) American Revolution 1775-83 2.4 War of 1812 1812-15 1.5 Mexican War 1846-49 2.4 Civil War(b) 1861-65 79.7 Spanish American War 1898-99 9.0 World War I 1917-21 334 World War II 1941-45 4,104 Korea 1950-53 341 Vietnam 1965-75 738 Persian Gulf War 1990-91 102 Post 9/11(c) 2001- 4,375 Source: Congressional Research Service (June 2010), Boston University (June 2014). (a) Constant 2011 dollars, except for Post 9/11 which is in current dollars. (b) Union and Confederacy added together. (c) Includes $1 trillion in future obligations for care of Veterans through 2054. One important fact stands out from this table. Not only are the Post 9/11 entanglements the longest of any war where the US was involved in, they are also the most expensive  –  even more than World War II, when the US was fighting on two major fronts against heavily industrialized powers. Rather than achieving victory quickly as advocated by Sun Tzu, the US has been involved in very costly wars for well over a decade now. When it comes to ensuring global security it can get lonely at the top. None of the traditional US allies have the military capabilities and even the ambition to project power at the same level. As an example, the US has 19 commissioned aircraft carriers, followed by France at #2 with only four. Russia and China only have one each. These days the US political establishment actively endorses this militaristic approach to governing world affairs. This might be understandable as the geopolitical landscape has become incredibly complex and  uncertain since 9/11. However, after years of waging war, conflict seems to be expanding as opposed to receding, particularly in the all-important Middle East where openly anti-Western radical groups are conquering large territories. As such, a complete US disentanglement over the foreseeable future looks increasingly less likely each day. Sun Tzu had something to say about this: “ Victorious warriors win first and then go to war, while defeated warriors go to war first and then seek to win. ” Seen in this light, has the Post 9/11 strategy made the US a victorious warrior? While all of this is taking place, the US ’  ideological foes can afford the luxury of sitting back and employing a more measured approach: “ To fight and conquer in all our battles is not supreme excellence; supreme excellence consists in breaking the enemy's resistance without fighting. ” Indeed, nothing breaks morale more than the prospect of never ending foreign wars. Meanwhile, the debts keep piling up. The Pentagon ’ s continued ability to project power might become increasingly dependent not on its brave soldiers but on its creditors. Sun Tzu would agree.
Search
Tags
Related Search
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks