School Work

2. Docena vs Lapesura

Description
cases
Categories
Published
of 9
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Related Documents
Share
Transcript
   THIRD DIVISION [G.R. No. 140153. March 28, 2001]ANTONIO DOCENA a! A #REDA DOCENA,  petitioners, vs . HON. RICARDO $. A$ES%RA, & h&' ca(ac&)* a' $r+'&!& -!+ o/ )h+ RTC, rach III, G&a, Ea')+r Saar R%#INO M. GARADO, Sh+r& IV a! CASIANO HOMRIA, respondents .D E C I S I O N GONAGARE6ES,  J .7  Th&' &' a (+)&)&o /or r+&+9 o c+r)&orar& !+r R:+ 45 o/ )h+ R:+' o/ Cor) '++;& )h+ ::&<ca)&o o/ )h+ Cor) o/ A((+a:' [1]  R+'o:)&o' !a)+! -+ 18, 1=== a! S+()+>+r =, 1=== 9h&ch !&'&''+! )h+ $+)&)&o /or C+r)&orar& a! $roh&>&)&o [2]  !+r R:+ ?5 a! !+&+! )h+ corr+'(o!& o)&o /or r+co'&!+ra)&o, r+'(+c)&+:*. Th+ a)+c+!+) /ac)' ar+ a' /o::o9'7O -+ 1, 1=@@, (r&a)+ r+'(o!+) Ca'&ao Ho>r&a <:+! a Co(:a&) /or )h+ r+co+r* o/ a (arc+: o/ :a! aa&') h&' :+''++', (+)&)&o+r'(o'+' A)o&o a! A:/r+!a Doc+a. [3]  Th+ (+)&)&o+r' c:a&+! o9+r'h&( o/ )h+ :a! >a'+! o occ(a)&o '&c+ )&+ &+or&a:. [4]  A c+r)a& G&::+ro A>!a &)+r++! & )h+ ca'+. I aD+c&'&o !a)+! No+>+r 24, 1=8=, )h+ )r&a: cor) r:+! & /aor o/ )h+ (+)&)&o+r' a! )h+ &)+r+or A>!a. [5]   O a((+a:, )h+ Cor) o/ A((+a:' r++r'+! )h+ !+) o/ )h+ )r&a: cor) a! or!+r+! )h+ (+)&)&o+r' B to vacate the land they have leased from the plainti-appellant [private respondent Casiano Hombria], excluding the  portion which the petitioners reclaimed from the sea and forms part of the shore, as shown in the Commissioners !eport, and to pay the  plainti-appellant the agreed rental of #$%% per year from the date of the &ling of the Complaint until they shall have actually vacated the premises . [?]  Th+ Co(:a&) & I)+r+)&o o/ A>!a 9a' !&'&''+!. [@] O Ma* 22, 1==5, (r&a)+ r+'(o!+) Ho>r&a <:+! a Mo)&o /or E+c)&o o/ )h+ a>o+ !+c&'&o 9h&ch ha' a:r+a!* >+co+ <a: a! ++c)or*. [8]  Th+ o)&o 9a' ra)+! >* )h+ (>:&c r+'(o!+) !+, a! a r&) o/ E+c)&o 9a' &''+! )h+r+/or. Ho9++r, )h+ (>:&c r+'(o!+) 'h+r& '>'+F+):* <:+! a Ma&/+')a)&o r+F+')& )ha) h+ B be clari&ed in the determination of that particular portion which issought to be excluded prior to the delivery of the land ad'udged in favor of plainti Casiano Hombria  & &+9 o/ )h+ !+/+c)' & )h+ Co&''&o+r' R+(or) a! )h+ S;+)ch+' a))ach+! )h+r+)o. [=]  A/)+r r+F&r& )h+ (ar)&+' )o <:+ )h+&r Co+) o )h+ 'h+r&' Ma&/+')a)&o, )h+ (>:&c r+'(o!+) !+, & a R+'o:)&o !a)+! A') 30, 1==?, h+:! )ha) B no attempt should be made to alter or modify the decision of the Court of (ppeals$ )hat should be delivered therefore to the plainti xxx is that portion leased by the defendant-appellees from the plainti-appellant excluding the portionthat the defendant-appellee have reclaimed from the sea and forms  part of the shore as shown in the commissioners report xxx$*  [10]    $r'a) )o )h+ R+'o:)&o, )h+ (>:&c r+'(o!+) 'h+r& &''+! a a lias  r&) o/ D+o:&)&o. Th+ (+)&)&o+r' <:+! a Mo)&o )o S+) A'&!+ or D+/+r )h+ I(:++)a)&o o/ r&) o/ D+o:&)&o. Th&' o)&o 9a' !+&+! >* )h+ (>:&c r+'(o!+) !+ & a Or!+r !a)+! No+>+r 18, 1==8, a co(* o/ 9h&ch 9a' r+c+&+! >* )h+ (+)&)&o+r' o D+c+>+r 2=, 1==8. [11]  A:'o o D+c+>+r 2=, 1==8, )h+ (>:&c r+'(o!+) !+, & o(+ cor), ra)+! )h+ (+)&)&o+r' )&: -aar* 13, 1=== )o <:+ a Mo)&o /or R+co'&!+ra)&o. [12]  O -aar* 13, 1===,(+)&)&o+r' o+! /or a +)+'&o o/ )h+ (+r&o! )o <:+ a o)&o /or r+co'&!+ra)&o )&: -aar* 28, 1===. [13]  Th+ o)&o 9a' <a::* <:+!>* )h+ (+)&)&o+r' o -aar* 2@, 1===, >) 9a' !+&+! >* )h+ )r&a: cor) & a Or!+r !a)+! March 1@, 1===. [14]  A co(* o/ )h+ Or!+r 9a' r+c+&+! >* )h+ (+)&)&o+r' o Ma* 4, 1===. [15] A $+)&)&o /or C+r)&orar& a! $roh&>&)&o 9a' <:+! >* )h+ (+)&)&o+r' 9&)h )h+ Cor) o/ A((+a:', a::+& ra+ a>'+ o/ !&'cr+)&o o )h+ (ar) o/ )h+ )r&a: cor) !+ & &''& )h+ Or!+r' !a)+! No+>+r 18, 1==8 a! March 1@, 1===, a! o/ )h+ 'h+r& & &''& )h+ alias  r&) o/ D+o:&)&o. I a R+'o:)&o !a)+! -+ 18, 1===, )h+ Cor) o/ A((+a:'!&'&''+! )h+ (+)&)&o o )h+ ro!' )ha) )h+ (+)&)&o 9a' <:+! >+*o! )h+ ?0!a* (+r&o! (ro&!+! !+r S+c)&o 4 o/ R:+ ?5 o/ )h+ 1==@ R+&'+! R:+' o/ C&&: $roc+!r+ a' a+!+! >* ar Ma))+r No. 803 ++c)&+ S+()+>+r 1, 1==8, a! )ha) )h+ c+r)&<ca)&o o/ o/or 'ho((& a))ach+! )h+r+)o 9a' '&+! >* o:* o+ o/ )h+ (+)&)&o+r'. [1?]  Th+ Mo)&o /or R+co'&!+ra)&o <:+! >* )h+ (+)&)&o+r' 9a' !+&+! >* )h+ Cor) o/ A((+a:' & a R+'o:)&o !a)+! S+()+>+r =, 1===. [1@] H+c+ )h&' (+)&)&o. Th+ 'o:+ &''+ & )h&' ca'+ &' 9h+)h+r or o) )h+ Cor) o/ A((+a:' +rr+! & !&'&''& )h+ $+)&)&o /or C+r)&orar& a! $roh&>&)&o. Th+ (+)&)&o &' +r&)or&o'. Th+ Cor) o/ A((+a:' !&'&''+! )h+ $+)&)&o /or C+r)&orar& (o )h+ /o::o9& ro!', vi+  7 1 )h+ (+)&)&o 9a' <:+! >+*o! )h+ ?0!a* (+r&o! (ro&!+! !+r S+c. 4, R:+ ?5 o/ )h+ 1==@ R+&'+! R:+' o/ C&&: $roc+!r+ a' a+!+! >* ar Ma))+r No. 803 ++c)&+ S+()+>+r 1, 1==8 a! 2 )h+ c+r)&<ca)&o o/ o/or 'ho((& 9a' '&+! >* o:* o+ o/ )h+ (+)&)&o+r'.%(o )h+ <r') ro!, )h+ Cor) o/ A((+a:' ')a)+! & &)' R+'o:)&o !a)+! -+ 18, 1=== )ha)7 )h+ ?0!a* (+r&o! &' co)+! o) /ro )h+ r+c+&() o/ )h+ Or!+r !+*& )h+&r Mo)&o /or R+co'&!+ra)&o >) /ro )h+ !a)+ o/ r+c+&() o/ )h+ Or!+r o/ No+>+r 18, 1==8 9h&ch 9a' o D+c+>+r 2=, 1==8,&)+rr()+! >* )h+ <:& o/ )h+ Mo)&o /or R+co'&!+ra)&o o -aar* 2@, 1===. Th+ Mo)&o /or R+co'&!+ra)&o 9a' !+&+! & a Or!+r !a)+! March 1@, 1=== r+c+&+! >* )h+ (+)&)&o+r' o Ma* 4, 1===. Co)& )h+ r+a&& (+r&o!, )h&' (+)&)&o 'ho:! ha+ >++ <:+! o -+ 4, 1=== >) &) 9a' <:+! o:* o -+ 14, 1=== or )+ 10 !a*' >+*o! )h+ ?0!a* (+r&o! co()+! & accor!ac+ 9&)h ar Ma))+r  No. 803.   [18]  Th+ (+)&)&o+r' ar++ )ha) )h+ co)& o/ )h+ ?0!a* (+r&o! 'ho:! co+c+ o D+c+>+r 2=, 1==8, )h+ !a)+ o/ )h+ r+c+&() >* )h+ (+)&)&o+r' o/ )h+ a''a&:+! )r&a: cor) or!+r, &)+rr()+! >* )h+ <:& o/ a o)&o /or r+co'&!+ra)&o o -aar* 2@, 1===, a! r+'+ (o r+c+&() >* )h+ (+)&)&o+r' o/ )h+ !+&a: o/ )h+ o)&o >* )h+ )r&a: cor) o Ma* 4, 1=== ho9++r, )h+ (+)&)&o+r' co)+! )ha) /ro D+c+>+r 2=, 1==8 ( )o -aar* 2@, 1===, o:* )h+ 15!a* (+r&o! a::o9+! /or )h+ <:& o/ a o)&o /or r+co'&!+ra)&o [1=]  'ho:! >+ !+++! )o ha+ +:a('+! co'&!+r& )h+ ra) >* )h+ )r&a: cor) o/ a +)+'&o o/ )h+ (+r&o! )o <:+ )h+ o)&o )&: -aar* 13, 1===. H+c+, o Ma* 4, 1===, )h+ (+)&)&o+r' ')&:: ha! 45 !a*' )o <:+ a (+)&)&o /or c+r)&orar& a!Jor (roh&>&)&o, a! )h+ <:& a!+ o -+ 14, 1=== 9a' )&+:*.+ ho:! )ha) )h+ $+)&)&o /or C+r)&orar& a! $roh&>&)&o ha' >++ )&+:*<:+!.A.M. No. 00203SC, 9h&ch )oo; ++c) o S+()+>+r 1, 2000, a+!+! S+c)&o 4 o/ R:+ ?5 o/ )h+ 1==@ R+&'+! R:+' o/ C&&: $roc+!r+ [20]  )o (ro&!+ )h'7SEC. 4.  )hen and where petition &led$--  Th+ (+)&)&o 'ha:: >+ <:+! o) :a)+r )ha '&)* ?0 !a*' /ro o)&c+ o/ )h+ !+), or!+r or r+'o:)&o. n case a motion for reconsideration or new trial is timely &led, whether such motion is reuired or not, the sixty ./%0 day  period shall be counted from notice of the denial of said motion$  Th+ (+)&)&o 'ha:: >+ <:+! & )h+ S(r++ Cor) or, &/ &) r+:a)+' )o )h+ ac)' or o&''&o' o/ a :o9+r cor) or o/ a cor(ora)&o, >oar!, oKc+r or(+r'o, & )h+ R+&oa: Tr&a: Cor) ++rc&'& r&'!&c)&o o+r )h+ )+rr&)or&a: ar+a a' !+<+! >* )h+ S(r++ Cor). I) a* a:'o >+ <:+! & )h+ Cor) o/ A((+a:' 9h+)h+r or o) )h+ 'a+ &' & a&! o/ &)' a((+::a)+ r&'!&c)&o, or & )h+ Sa!&a>a*a &/ &) &' & a&! o/ &)' a((+::a)+ r&'!&c)&o. I/ &) &o:+' )h+ ac)' or o&''&o' o/ a Fa'& !&c&a: a+c*, :+'' o)h+r9&'+ (ro&!+! >* :a9 or )h+'+ r:+', )h+ (+)&)&o 'ha:: >+ <:+! & a! co&La>:+ o:* >* )h+ Cor) o/ A((+a:'.No +)+'&o o/ )&+ )o <:+ )h+ (+)&)&o 'ha:: >+ ra)+! +c+() /or co(+::& r+a'o a! & o ca'+ +c++!& </)++ 15 !a*'. [E(ha'&' or']I )h+ ca'+ o/ 1ystems 2actors Corporation versus 34!C , [21]  9+ h+:! )ha) )h+ a>o+Fo)+! R+'o:)&o, >+& (roc+!ra: & a)r+, &' a((:&ca>:+ )o ac)&o' (+!& a! !+)+r&+! a) )h+ )&+ o/ )h+&r (a''a+. Th+ r+)roac)&+ a((:&ca)&o o/ (roc+!ra: :a9' 'ch a' )h&' R+'o:)&o &' o) &o:a)&+ o/ a* r&h) o/ a (+r'o 9ho a* /++: a!+r'+:* a+c)+! )h+r+>*, a' o +')+! r&h) a* a))ach )o or ar&'+/ro (roc+!ra: :a9'. [22]  Th+ r:& & )h+ 1ystems 2actors  ca'+ 9a' r+&)+ra)+! & )h+ r+c+) ca'+ o/ 5nity 2ishing 6evelopment Corporation, et$ al$ vs$ Court of (ppeals, et$ al . [23]  A((:*& )h+ R+'o:)&o )o )h+ ca'+ a) >ar, )h+ ?0!a* (+r&o! /or )h+ <:& o/ a  (+)&)&o /or c+r)&orar& a! (roh&>&)&o 'ho:! >+ r+c;o+! /ro )h+ !a)+ o/ r+c+&() o/ )h+ or!+r !+*& )h+ o)&o /or r+co'&!+ra)&o, &.+., Ma* 4, 1===, a! )h', )h+ <:& a!+ o -+ 14, 1=== 9a' 9+:: 9&)h& )h+ ?0!a* r+:++)ar* (+r&o!.A+) )h+ ro! )ha) )h+ c+r)&<ca)&o o/ o/or 'ho((& 9a' '&+! >* o:* o+ o/ )h+ (+)&)&o+r', &) &' )h+ co)+)&o o/ )h+ (+)&)&o+r' )ha) )h+ 'a+ &' 'Kc&+) co(:&ac+ 9&)h )h+ r+F&r++)' o/ S+c)&o' 1 a! 2 o/ R:+ ?5 $+)&)&o /or C+r)&orar& a!$roh&>&)&o & r+:a)&o )o S+c)&o 3 o/ R:+ 4? Or&&a: Ca'+' #&:+! & )h+ Cor) o/ A((+a:'. Th+ (+)&)&o+r' ar+ )ha) '&c+ )h+* ar+ '(o'+' 9&)h o&) or &!&&'&>:+ &)+r+') o+r )h+ a::++! coa: (ro(+r)* '>+c) o/ )h+ or&&a: ac)&o 9h&ch a+ r&'+ )o )h+ (+)&)&o /or c+r)&orar& a! (roh&>&)&o, )h+ '&& o/ )h+ c+r)&<ca)+ o/ o/or 'ho((& >* o:* o+ o/ )h+ 9o:! 'Kc+, +'(+c&a::* co'&!+r& )h+ :o !&')ac+ )h+* ha! )o )ra+: ') )o '& )h+ 'a&! c+r)&<ca)+. [24]  Mor+o+r, )h+r+ &' '>')a)&a: co(:&ac+ 9&)h )h+ R:+' o/ Cor) 9h+r+ )h+ c+r)&<ca)&o 9a' '&+! >* )h+ h'>a! 9ho &' )h+ ')a))or* a!&&')ra)or o/ )h+ coa: (ro(+r)*. [25] I) ha' >++ or (r+&o' r:& )ha) )h+ c+r)&<ca)+ o/ o/or 'ho((& 'ho:! >+ '&+! >* a:: )h+ (+)&)&o+r' or (:a&)&' & a ca'+,a! )ha) )h+ '&& >* o:* o+ o/ )h+ &' &'Kc&+). I )h+ ca'+ o/ 7fren 4ouias, et$ al$ vs$ 89ce of the 8mbudsman, et$ al ., [2?]  9+ h+:! )ha) )h+ '&& o/ )h+ V+r&<ca)&o a! )h+ C+r)&<ca)&o o No#or Sho((& >* o:* o+ o/ )h+ (+)&)&o+r' co')&))+' a !+/+c) & )h+ (+)&)&o. [2@]  Th+ a))+')a)&o co)a&+! & )h+ c+r)&<ca)&o o o/or 'ho((& r+F&r+'  personal :nowledge  >* )h+ (ar)* ++c)& )h+ 'a+, [28]  a! )h+ :o+ '&& (+)&)&o+r cao) >+ (r+'+! )o ha+ (+r'oa: ;o9:+!+ o/ )h+ <:& or o<:& >* h&' co(+)&)&o+r' o/ a* ac)&o or c:a& )h+ 'a+ a' or '&&:ar )o )h+ crr+)(+)&)&o. To +r&) )h+ Cor)' co'&!+ra)&o, (+)&)&o+r' ') 'ho9 r+a'oa>:+ ca'+ /or /a&:r+ )o (+r'oa::* '& )h+ c+r)&<ca)&o.I )h+ ca'+ a) >ar, ho9++r, 9+ ho:! )ha) )h+ '>+c) C+r)&<ca)+ o/ No#or Sho((& '&+! >* )h+ (+)&)&o+r A)o&o Doc+a a:o+ 'ho:! >+ !+++! )o co')&))+ '>')a)&a: co(:&ac+ 9&)h )h+ r:+'. [2=]  Th+r+ ar+ o:* )9o (+)&)&o+r' & )h&' ca'+ a! )h+* ar+ h'>a! a! 9&/+. Th+&r r+'&!+c+ &' )h+ '>+c) (ro(+r)* a::++! )o >+ coa: & )h+ &')a) +r&<+! (+)&)&o. Th+ V+r&<ca)&oJC+r)&<ca)&o o No#or Sho((& [30]  a))ach+! )o )h+ $+)&)&o /or C+r)&orar& a! $roh&>&)&o 9a' '&+! o:* >* )h+ h'>a! 9ho c+r)&<+!, inter alia , )ha) h+ a! h&' 9&/+ ha+ o) co+c+! a* o)h+r ac)&o or (roc++!& &o:& )h+ 'a+ &''+' ra&'+! & )h+ (+)&)&o & a* cor), )r&>a: or Fa'&!&c&a: a+c* )ha) )o )h+ >+') o/ )h+&r ;o9:+!+ o 'ch ac)&o &' (+!& )h+r+& a! )ha) h+ a! h&' 9&/+!+r)a;+ )o &/or )h+ Cor) 9&)h& <+ 5 !a*' /ro o)&c+ o/ a* '&&:ar ac)&o or (roc++!& 9h&ch a* ha+ >++ <:+!. Th+ (ro(+r)* '>+c) o/ )h+ or&&a: ac)&o /or r+co+r* &' coa:. h+)h+r &) &' coa: !+r )h+ N+9 C&&: Co!+ or )h+ #a&:* Co!+, a /ac) )ha) cao) >+ !+)+r&+! /ro )h+ r+cor!' >+/or+ ', &) &' >+:&++! )ha) )h+ c+r)&<ca)+ o o/or 'ho((& <:+! & )h+ Cor)

1. Gayon vs Gayon

Jul 23, 2017

4. Manacop vs CA

Jul 23, 2017
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks
SAVE OUR EARTH

We need your sign to support Project to invent "SMART AND CONTROLLABLE REFLECTIVE BALLOONS" to cover the Sun and Save Our Earth.

More details...

Sign Now!

We are very appreciated for your Prompt Action!

x