Law

A study in the expressiveness of semantically different policy modelling schemes

Description
A study in the expressiveness of semantically different policy modelling schemes
Categories
Published
of 4
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Related Documents
Share
Transcript
  ! #$%&' () $*+ +,-.+##(/+)+## 01 #+23)$(4355' &(11+.+)$ -05(4' 20&+55()6 #4*+2+# 7*.(#$0# 8#3.0%4*(#9 :+453) ;<=%55(/3)9 :3/(& >+?(# @)0?5+&6+ A :3$3 B)6()++.()6 C.0%- D@:BCE :+-3.$2+)$ 01 702-%$+. =4(+)4+ A =$3$(#$(4#9 8.()($' 7055+6+ :%F5()9 :%F5()9 G.+53)& H$#3.0%44 I :+453)J;=%55(/3) I :3/+J>+?(#KL4#J$4&J(+  !"#$%&'$   ! #$%&'( )*+&*,,-&*+ &. /0, 1-$',.. $2 34/0$-&*+ 56 73*3+,7,*/ 1$%&'&,.8 9,/,'/&*+ 3*9 -,.$%:&*+ 1$%&'( '$*2%&'/. 3*9 -,:&.&*+ ,;&./&*+ 1$%&'&,. /$ 3''$77$93/, '03*+&*+ 56 -,.$4-',.8 <4.&*,.. +$3%. 3*9 <4.&*,.. 1-$',..,.= #$%&'( 34/0$-&*+ &. $2/,* 2$%%$>,9 <( 1$%&'( ,*2$-',7,*/ >0,-, /0, 3'/&$*. .1,'&2&,9 <( .4<?,'/. 3-, 1,-2$-7,9 $* /3-+,/. @-,.$4-',.A= 5* /0&. 131,-8 >, ./49( /0, 4., $2 .,73*/&'3%%( ,*03*',9 /,'0*&B4,.8 .4'0 3. $*/$%$+&,.8 /$ 7$9,% %(#)*%'(#  3*9 /0,&- '$--,.1$*9&*+ &'$+),#-  '$41%,9 >&/0 3 7,'03*&.7 /03/ '3* 3''$77$93/, 2-,B4,*/ $-+3*&C3/&$*3% '03*+,8 /$ 7$9,% 1$%&'( #*".('$#/  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 0(12)%3#4 67 8)9+'1 (,:+,((%+,:- 8)9+'1 ;)3(9+,:- <= &,3 => +,$(:%&$+), GJ   G  M8N;:O78G;M P05(4' B)6()++.()6 (# $*+ -.04+## 01 3%$*0.()6 G8 23)36+2+)$ -05(4(+#9 &+$+4$()6 3)& .+#05/()6 -05(4' 40)15(4$# 3)& .+/(#()6 +,(#$()6 -05(4(+# $0 3440220&3$+ 4*3)6()6 G8 .+#0%.4+#9 F%#()+## 6035# 3)& F%#()+## -.04+##+#QRSJ P05(4' 3%$*0.()6 (# 01$+) 10550?+& F' -05(4' +)10.4+2+)$ ?*+.+ $*+ 34$(0)# #-+4(1(+& F' #%FT+4$# 3.+ -+.10.2+& 0) $3.6+$# D.+#0%.4+#EJ G) $*(# -3-+.9 ?+ #$%&' $*+ %#+ 01 #+23)$(4355' +)*3)4+& $+4*)(U%+#9 #%4* 3# 0)$0506(+#9 $0 20&+5 !"#$%!&"#  3)& $*+(. 40..+#-0)&()6 '&()$*#+  40%-5+& ?($* 3 2+4*3)(#2 $*3$ 43) 3440220&3$+ 1.+U%+)$ 0.63)(V3$(0)35 4*3)6+9 $0 20&+5 -05(4'  #%,-"&(#. ;$*+. .+#+3.4* ()($(3$(/+# *3/+ 3$$+2-$+& $0 #05/+ #%4* -.0F5+2# F' 402F()()6 $*+ +11(4(+)4' 3)& $*+ +,-.+##(/+ -0?+. 01 .%5+WF3#+& #'#$+2# ?($* $*+ #+23)$(4 .(4*)+## 10%)& () :+#4.(-$(0) >06(4# QXSJ Y0. ()#$3)4+9 3 .%5+WF3#+& #'#$+2 43) +,-.+## /3.(3F5+# 3)& 43%#35($' .+53$(0)#*(-# ?*+.+3# 0)$0506(+# 0) $*+ 0$*+. *3)&9 43) .+-.+#+)$ .+53$(0)#*(-# F+$?++) +)$($(+# () 3 $3,0)02(4 23))+. $*3$ 40%5& #(2-5(1' 23()$3()3F(5($'J G) $*(# -3-+.9 10. $*+ 20&+5()6 01 -05(4' #%FT+4$#9 $*+ .%5+W F3#+& 7022%)($'WF3#+& P05(4' 23)36+2+)$ ?(55 F+ %#+&J 8*(# ()$+6.3$(0) 1355# ()$0 $*+ 43$+60.' 01 402F()()6 :+#4.(-$(0) >06(4# D:>E QZS 3)& >06(4 P.06.32# D>PE Q[SJ \+ 3(2 $0 #$%&' $*(# ()$+6.3$(0) -.(23.(5' 1.02 $*+ #40-+ 01 0/+.355 #'#$+2 +,-.+##(/($'9 3# ?+55 3# 1.02 $*+ #40-+ 01 2()(2(V()6 $*+ 406)($(/+ 503& Q]S -+.4+(/+& F' -05(4' 3%$*0.#9 ?*(4* (#  -3.$(4%53.5' (2-0.$3)$ () 40553F0.3$(/+ +)/(.0)2+)$#9 ?($* 2%5$(-5+ -05(4' 3%$*0.#J GGJ   ^ BMBYG8= ;Y O=GMC =B_!M8G7!>>` BMa!M7B: NB=;ON7B=  ;)+ 01 $*+ .+U%(.+2+)$# () -05(4' +)6()++.()6 (# $*+ )++& $0 *3/+ 3) 344%.3$+ 3)& %-W$0W&3$+ /(+? 01 $*+ 23)36+& !"#$%!&"#  3# ?+55 3# 01 $*+ '&()$*#  $*3$ 43) F+ -+.10.2+& 0) $*+#+ .+#0%.4+#J 8*(# (# -3.$(4%53.5' 4*355+)6()6 () $*+ 43#+ ?*+) )0$ 0)5' $*+#+ .+#0%.4+# 3.+ 1.+U%+)$5' 4*3)6()6 F%$ 35#0 ?*+) $*+(. 40..+#-0)&()6 34$(0)# 4*3)6+ 3# ?+55J Y0. ()#$3)4+9 %#()6 $*+ +,32-5+ #*0?) () QbS 9 ?+ 3##%2+ $*3$ 3 40.-0.3$(0) )++&# $0 c++- 3 .+40.& 01 355 3##+$# $*+'  -0##+##9 #%4* 3# )+$?0.c .0%$+.#9 #+./+.#9 P7#9 +$49 3# ?+55 3# 3 5(#$ 01 40%)$+.2+3#%.+# $*3$ )++& $0 F+ $3c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 -05(4' 01 $*+ 10550?()6 10.2d eG)#$355 #01$?3.+ %-&3$+ f 0) 355 3--5(43F5+ &+/(4+#gJ !# $*+ 402-5+,($' 01 $*+ 23)36+& .+#0%.4+# (# ()4.+3#()69 $*+ +)10.4+2+)$ 01 #%4* 3 *(6* 5+/+5  -05(4' -0#+# 3 /+.' 4*355+)6()6 -.0F5+2J 8*(# -05(4' ?0%5& .+U%(.+ ($# e.+1()+2+)$g ()$0 $*+ 3--.0-.(3$+ 50?W5+/+5 -05(4(+#9 #02+$*()6 $*3$ 01$+) $3c+# /3.(0%# #$36+# 01 6.3&%35 .+1()+2+)$ %)$(5 $*+ -05(4' .+34*+# 3) +)10.4+3F5+ #$36+J ;)+ -0##(F5+ #05%$(0) 40%5& F+ $0 -%#* $*+ )++& $0 c)0? 355 3F0%$ $*+ .+#0%.4+# 3)& $*+(. 40..+#-0)&()6 34$(0)# 3# 53$+ () $*+ -05(4' +)6()++.()6 5(1+4'45+ 3# -0##(F5+J 8*(# ?0%5& )0$ 0)5' 3##(#$  -05(4' 3%$*0.()6 F' 3F#$.34$()6 3?3' D1.+U%+)$5' 4*3)6()6E &+$3(5# 3F0%$ $*+ 23)36+& #'#$+29 F%$ 43) -.0/(&+ U%35($'  0""1,'&2   3# ?+559 () 43#+ 01 -05(4' 40)15(4$#J 8*(# 43) F+ 34*(+/+& F' *3/()6 3) %-W$0W&3$+ #)3-#*0$ 01 $*+ .+#0%.4+# 3)&  $*+(. 40..+#-0)&()6 34$(0)# () U%+#$(0) ()$0 3 #$.%4$%.+&9 23)36+3F5+ 3)& +3#' $0 U%+.' c)0?5+&6+ F3#+ D@^EJ 8*(# @^ 43) F+ .+-.+#+)$+& %#()6 0)$0506(435 .+-.+#+)$3$(0)#J 8*(# (#  F+43%#+ $*+ %#+ 01 0)$0506(+# 43) -.0/(&+ 3 4+)$.35(V+& 10.2 01 c)0?5+&6+ 366.+63$(0)9 ?*+) +/+) 402-5+, .+53$(0)#*(-# 43)  F+ &+#4.(F+& 3)& U%+.(+&J O#()6 ;\> :> QhS 10. ()#$3)4+9 $*+ e+U%(/35+)$g 3)& e&(#T0()$g .+53$(0)#*(-# F+$?++) .+#0%.4+# 3)& 34$(0)# 43) F+ &+#4.(F+&J G) 0%. +,32-5+9 &+/(4+# *3/()6 &(11+.+)$ 0-+.3$()6 #'#$+2# 40%5& F+ ()#$3)4+# 01 #%F453##+# &+#4.(F()6 $*+(. .+#-+4$(/+ 0-+.3$()6 #'#$+29 ?*(4* () $%.)  F+50)6 $0 3 40220) #%-+.W453## 01 i0-+.3$()6 #'#$+2#<J a0?+/+.9 () $+.2# 01 -+.10.2()6 #01$?3.+ %-&3$+#9 3# #-+4(1(+& () 0%. +,32-5+9 $*0#+ #%F453##+# )++& $0 F+ &(#T0()$J 8*(# ()10.23$(0) 43) -0$+)$(355' F+ F+)+1(4(35 10. -05(4' 3%$*0.# () 3/0(&()6 -05(4' 40)15(4$#9 +J6J F' -+.10.2()6 %-&3$+# 0) $*+ 3--.0-.(3$+ &+/(4+ 0)5'J =\N> QjS %#+# $*+ -0?+. 01 .%5+# 10. .%5+ +)10.4+2+)$ 3)& $*+ -0?+. 01 ;\> :> $0 10.2 355 .%5+ -.+&(43$+#J ;)+ c+' &(11+.+)4+ F+$?++) =\N> 3)& $*+ .+#+3.4* -.+#+)$+& () $*(#  -3-+. (# $*3$ ?+ 3.+ ()/+#$(63$()6 ?*+$*+. 0)$0506(+# 43)  -.0/(&+ F+)+1($# ?*+) %#+& $0 20&+5 -05(4' ('!3"(#  3)& $*+(. '&()$*#+  F%$ $*(# (# () 3 1.32+?0.c ?*+.+ 3$$.34$(/+ 35$+.)3$(/+# 10. 20&+5()6 $*+ #-+4(1(4 ()$+.34$(0)# F+$?++) -05(4'  #%,-"&(#  35.+3&' +,(#$J N05+WF3#+& !44+## 70)$.05 DN^!7E QkS 35.+3&' .+-.+#+)$# 3 ?(&+5' 344+-$+& #$.%4$%.+ 10. 20&+5()6 -05(4' #%FT+4$#J a0?+/+.9 0%. -.+/(0%# ?0.c *3# (&+)$(1(+& $*3$ $*+ )++& $0 43-$%.+ $*+  04$5 $0 '%(6$!)(7  (# .+U%(.+& QRSJ >3.6+ 0.63)(V3$(0)# *3/+ &+4(#(0)W23c()6 6.0%-#9 ?*(4* 3.+ %#%355' *(+.3.4*(435 () )3$%.+ 3)& 01$+) 1"4"3'("  $*+ &+4(#(0) 3%$*0.($' $0 0$*+. 6.0%-# 50?+. () $*+ *(+.3.4*'J 80 20&+5 #%4* 40)4+-$# $*+ %#+ 01 $*+ 0)$0506(435 453##W#%F453## .+53$(0)#*(- (# )0$ 3&+U%3$+J Y0. +,32-5+9 3 402-3)'<# :(.+4$0. *3# 3%$*0.($' 0/+. $*+ P.0T+4$ >+3&9 F%$ $*+ 53$$+. (# )0$ 3 #%F453## 01 $*+ 10.2+.J G) .+35($' *0?+/+.9 &+4(#(0)W23c()6 6.0%-# 3.+ 20.+ 15%(& 3)& 0/+.53--()6 $*3) $*+ 453##(4 *(+.3.4*(435 0.63)(V3$(0)35 20&+5# $*3$ %)&+.-() .05+WF3#+& #4*+2+#J Y0. $*(# -%.-0#+9 $*(# .+#+3.4* ?(55 %#+ $*+ 7022%)($'WF3#+& P05(4' _3)36+2+)$ D7^P_E QRlS 1.32+?0.c $0 20&+5 -05(4' #%FT+4$#9 ?*(4* *3# F++) #*0?) $0 20&+5 $*+ 0.63)(V3$(0)35 3#-+4$# 01 -05(4' #%FT+4$ 20&+5# () 3 ?3' $*3$ 23c+# $*+ .+#%5$()6 -05(4' F3#+ 20.+ .0F%#$ $0 0.63)(V3$(0)35 4*3)6+ QRRSJ G) $*(# -3-+. ?+ $*+.+10.+ 3(2 $0 ()/+#$(63$+ *0? &(11+.+)$ 402F()3$(0)# 01 :> 3)& >P (2-34$ 0) $*+ 0/+.355 #'#$+2 +,-.+##(/+)+## 3)& 0) $*+ 406)($(/+ 503& -534+& %-0) $*+ .+U%(.+2+)$# +)6()++.9 ?*(5+ 3(2()6 10. 3 #(2(53. 5+/+5 01  -05(4' +)6()++.()6 .0F%#$)+## 10. $3.6+$ 20&+5#9 ?*(4* 7^P_ &+5(/+.# 10. #%FT+4$ 20&+5#J 7^P_ %#+# $*+ )0$(0) 01 8$99%*)(7  3# $*+ -.(23.' 6.0%-()6 3F#$.34$(0) ?($* $*+ 3(2 01 3550?()6 6.0%-# ?($*() $*+ 0.63)(V3$(0) ($#+51 $0 &+1()+ 4022%)($(+# $0 )3$%.355' .+15+4$ $*+ 4*3)6()6 )3$%.+ 01 &+4(#(0) 23c()6 D(J+J -05(4' #+$$()6E 3%$*0.($'J 7022%)($(+# $0?3.&# $*+ $0- 01 $*+ *(+.3.4*' *3/+ $*+ ?(&+. 2+2F+.#*(- 3)& 20.+ 6+)+.35 1%)4$(0)9 ?*(5+ $*0#+ $0?3.& $*+ F0$$02 *3/+ 20.+ )3..0? 2+2F+.#*(- 3)& 20.+ #-+4(1(4 1%)4$(0)J 8*+ *(+.3.4*' (# &+#(6)+& $0 #%--0.$ 36(5($' 3)& 3%$0)02'9 3550?()6 )+? #%FW4022%)($(+# $0 F+ 10.2+& 3)& +)40%.36()6 $*+ &+5+63$(0) 01 &+4(#(0) 23c()6 3%$*0.($' 3# 13. &0?) $*+ *(+.3.4*' 3# -0##(F5+J O#()6 7^P_ +)3F5+# %# $0 *3/+ 3 -0?+.1%5  :"!9)##)$*# #&6"9" () -534+J 8*(# #4*+2+ 6.3)$# 0. &+)(+# -+.2(##(0) $0 -+.10.2 34$(0)# 0) .+#0%.4+# 3)& ($ 43) 35#0 F+ %#+& $0 &+1()+ 0F5(63$(0)#J GGGJ   : B=7NGP8G;M > ;CG7 D:>E  !M: > ;CG7 P N;CN!__GMC D>PE  GM8BCN!8G;M  ^+10.+ ?+ -.+#+)$ () &+$3(5 $*+ ()$+6.3$(0) &+$3(5# 01 ;\> :> 3)& 7^P_9 ($ (# ?0.$* -.+#+)$()6 3) 0/+./(+? 01 $*+ :+#4.(-$(0) >06(4 3)& >06(4 P.06.322()6 ()$+6.3$(0)J 8*+ ()$+6.3$(0) F+$?++) 0)$0506(+# 3)& .%5+# 43) F+ 43$+60.(V+& ()$0 6$9$3"*"$%#  3)& 67,!)1   ()$+6.3$(0) QXSJ G) $*+ *0206+)+0%# 3--.034*9 0)$0506(+# 3)& .%5+# 3.+ +2F+&&+& ()$0 3 )+? 506(435 53)6%36+ ! J 8*+ .%5+ -.+&(43$+# $*3$ 10.2 $*+ 0-+.3$(0)35 -05(4(+#9 %#+ 0)$0506' 40)4+-$# #%4* 3# 0)$0506' -.0-+.$(+# 0. ()#$3)4+#J =\N> 1355# ()$0 $*(# 43$+60.'9 3# ($ (# 3) +,$+)#(0) 01 ;\> :> 3,(02# ?($* .%5+ 3,(02#J =\N> .%5+# 43) F+ %#+& $0 &+1()+ )+? 453##+# 3)& )+? -.0-+.$(+# 01 $*+ 0)$0506'J   G) $*+ *'F.(& 3--.034*9 $*+.+ (# 3 #+-3.3$(0) F+$?++) $*+ 0)$0506(435 3)& $*+ .%5+ -.+&(43$+#J 8*+ 0)$0506' .+23()# %)4*3)6+& 3)& .%5+# 3.+ F%(5$ 0) $0- 01 0)$0506(+#J  ;.   8<=> '*1 ?@A BA )*("3!'()$* 8*+ $'-+ 01 ()$+6.3$(0) F+$?++) 7^P_ 3)& ;\> :>  -.+#+)$+& () $*(# -3-+.9 (# 01 $*+ *'F.(& $'-+9 ?*(4* 2+3)# $*3$ $*+.+ (# )0 4.+3$(0) 01 3 )+? 506(435 53)6%36+J 8*+ .+#%5$()6 1.32+?0.c (# 4355+& 8<=>CBA J 7^P_m:> (# 10.2+& 3# 10550?#d 3 *'F.(& c)0?5+&6+ F3#+   @ n D=9NE (# 3 1()($+ #+$ = 01 :> 3,(02# () $*+ 0)$0506' 53)6%36+ = 3)& 3 1()($+ #+$ 01 *'F.(& .%5+# N 0/+. N 3)& =9 ()45%&()6 )0)W:> 3$02#J 8*(# &+1()($(0) 10550?# $*+ *'F.(& ()$+6.3$(0) &+1()($(0) -.+#+)$+& () QXSJ =()4+ $*+ 7^P_m:> 2+$*0& 10550?# $*(# *'F.(& 3--.034*9 $*+ #+23)$(4# +)$3(5+& () $*+ *'F.(& 53)6%36+ 3.+ &+.(/+& 1.02 $*+ #+23)$(4# 01 ($# 40)#$($%+)$ 402-0)+)$#9 )32+5' 7^P_ 3)& ;\> :>J ! *'F.(& .%5+ . (# 0F$3()+& 1.02 $*+ 7^P_ .%5+ .  ′ 9 F' 3&&()6 :> U%+.(+# () $*+ F0&'J 8*+ 53$$+. 3.+ () 134$ 3&&($(0)35 40)#$.3()$# 0) $*+ %#+ 01 $*+ .%5+ .  ′ 9 ?*(4* *3/+ $0 F+ #3$(#1(+& #0 $*3$ $*+ .%5+ .  ′  (# 1(.+&J  <.   8<=>CBA #7*('D 8*+ #')$3, 01 7^P_m:> (# 10.2+& F' +,$+)&()6 $*+ +,(#$()6 7^P_ #')$3, ?($* 0)$0506(435 -.+&(43$+#J 8?0 01 $*+ 20#$ (2-0.$3)$ $'-+ 01 .%5+# $*3$ 60/+.) 7^P_ 3.+ 9"9,"!#6): !%4"# 9 ?*(4* &+1()+ $*+ .%5+# 10. 3) +)$($' $0 F+ 3 2+2F+. 01 3 -3.$(4%53. 7022%)($' 3)& $*+ '%(6$!)E'()$* !%4"# 9 ?*(4* 6.3)$ 0. &+)' -+.2(##(0) $0 3) +)$($' $0 -+.10.2 3) 34$(0) 0) 3 -3.$(4%53. .+#0%.4+J ^0$* 2+2F+.#*(- 3)& 3%$*0.(V3$(0) .%5+# *3/+ F++) +,$+)&+& ?($* 0)$0506(435  -.+&(43$+#J FG   8$99%*)(7 >"9,"!#6): H%4" 8*+ 2+2F+.#*(- .%5+ &+1()+# $*+ .+#$.(4$(0)# $*3$ )++& $0 F+ #3$(#1(+&9 10. 3 -+.#0) P $0 F+ 3 2+2F+. 01 7022%)($' 7J "#$%&'()"* ∧  ,$&,#$-./)" →  0#01#$23()"4 5&006'7-.* P.0-+.$' (# 01 $'-+ 0)$0506(435 0FT+4$ -.0-+.$' .+#$.(4$(0)J 8*(# 2+3)# $*3$ %#+.W#-+4(1(4 -.0-+.$(+# 43) F+ 4.+3$+&J IG    ;%(6$!)E'()$* H%4"  !%$*0.(V3$(0) (# 3F0%$ 6.3)$()6 0. &+)'()6 344+## D)+63$(/+ 3%$*0.(V3$(0)E $0 3 #%FT+4$ $0 -+.10.2 3) 34$(0) 0) 3 .+#0%.4+J G) $*(# .+#+3.4* ?+ %#+ $*+ )0$(0) 01 !"#$%!&" '%(6$!)(7+ ?*(4* (# ()$.0&%4+& () 7^P_J ! .+#0%.4+ 3%$*0.($' #-+4(1(+# ?*3$ 34$(0) 0) ?*(4* .+#0%.4+9 344+## (# #0%6*$ 10.J 8*+ .+#0%.4+ 3%$*0.($' (# &+1()+& 3# 10550?#d 89-7&'():* ∧  ;#%&6$9#()$* →  ;#%&6$9#86-<&$7-.()$:* 8*+ .+#0%.4+ 3%$*0.($' (# %#+& 3# 3 -.+&(43$+ () $*+ 3%$*0.(V3$(0) .%5+d 9&00()9&00* ∧  7%:()=4 ).* →  ,&%86-<()9&004 )$:* 8*+ (#3Do,9 o'E &+)0$+# $*+ ;\> (#W3 .+53$(0)#*(-9 3)& () $*(# 43#+ ($ 2+3)# $*3$ , (# 3 #%F453## 01 'J 8*(# .%5+ 43) F+ .+3& $*3$ 3# 50)6 3# $*+ e(#3g .+53$(0)#*(- (# #3$(#1(+&9 $*+ 4022%)($' &$99 9 (# 3%$*0.(V+& $0 -+.10.2 3) 34$(0) 0) 3 .+#0%.4+9 3# #-+4(1(+& () $*+ .+#0%.4+ 3%$*0.($' .+#$.(4$(0)J JG    K9:4)"# '%(6$!)(7 !%4" 8*+ )9:4)"# '%(6$!)(7  .+53$(0)#*(- &+#4.(F+# $*+ 3%$*0.($' ?*(4* (# +,+.4(#+& F' 3 7022%)($'9 3) !4$(0)9 3)& 3 N+#0%.4+ 0) 3 7022%)($' ′ 9 3) !4$(0) ′  3)& 3 N+#0%.4+ ′  .+#-+4$(/+5'9 ?*(4* 3.+ 5043$+& 50?+. () $*+ *(+.3.4*' 01 3%$*0.($'J 5&006'7-. >0,?7#%86-<&$7-.2@#$ 5&006'7-. ′  89-7&' >0,?7#%86-<&$7-.2@#$ 89-7&' ′  ;#%&6$9# >0,?7#%86-<&$7-.2@#$ ;#%&6$9# ′   ′ d 50?+. () $*+ *(+.3.4*(435 $.++ Y0. +,32-5+9 $*+ 7022%)($' 4355+&  B)!"&($!#  G2-5(+#!%$*0.($';/+. $*+ 7022%)($' ′  4355+&  =!$-"&(# A"'1# J 8*+ !4$(0)  H"'1 ;44   G2-5(+#!%$*0.($';/+.  H"'1 L)4". 8*+ N+#0%.4+ M"!N"!#  G2-5(+#!%$*0.($';/+.  B'(','#" M"!N"!#. OG    H"#$%!&" '%(6$!)(7 B"4"3'()$* !%4" 8*+ &+5+63$(0) .%5+ &+)0$+# $*3$ 10. 3 -3.$(4%53. 40)&($(0)9 $*+ N+#0%.4+ !%$*0.($' o.3 (# &+5+63$+& 1.02 4022%)($' 7 $0 4022%)($' 7 ′ 9 ?*+.+ 7022%)($' 7 ′  (# 50?+. () $*+ *(+.3.4*' 01 3%$*0.($' $*3) 4022%)($' 7J 8.   PK9:4)"# '%(6$!)(7Q N# P)#R'Q !"4'()$*#6):# ;)+ 01 $*+ 23() &.(/+# 10. $*(# .+#+3.4* () -%.#%()6 $*+ ()$+6.3$(0) 01 7^P_ ?($* ;\> :> (# $*+ .+35(V3$(0) 01 $*+  F+)+1($# $*3$ F0$* $+4*)0506(+# 43) 011+. () -05(4' +)6()++.()6J ^' %#()6 7^P_ 10. 20&+5()6 -05(4' #%FT+4$#9 ($# 3F(5($' 01 *3)&5()6 4*3)6+ 3$ $*+ 0.63)(V3$(0)35 5+/+5 43) F+ %$(5(V+&J 8*(# 43) F+ 34*(+/+& $*.0%6* $*+ %#+ 01 ($# 15+,(F5+ 8$99%*)(7  6.0%-()6 3F#$.34$(0) 3)& #02+ 01 ($# 0$*+. )3$(/+ 40)#$.%4$#9 #%4* 3# $*+ e )9:4)"# '%(6$!)(7Q .+53$(0)#*(- 3)& $*+ &+5+63$(0) 01 !"#$%!&" '%(6$!)()"# J 8*+ ;\> :> 1.32+?0.c 0) $*+ 0$*+. *3)& (# ?+55 c)0?) 10. ($# #%F#%2-$(0) 3F(5($(+# D#%FW453## 3)& #%FW-.0-+.$' .+53$(0)#*(-#EJ Y0. +,32-5+9 $*+ 3F(5($' $0 402F()+ $*+ e(2-5(+# 3%$*0.($'g ?($* $*+ #%F453## .+53$(0)#*(-# *3# F++) -.0/+) +,$.+2+5' *+5-1%5 () &+#4.(F()6 /3.(0%# #4+)3.(0#J G) $*+ +)40&()6 01 $*+ 87: #$3$%$+# 43#+ #$%&' $*3$ ?(55 F+ -.+#+)$+& F+50?9 $*+ (2-0.$3)4+ () $*+ 40W+,(#$+)4+ 01 $*+ $?0 .+53$(0)#*(-# ?(55 F+ *(6*5(6*$+&J GpJ   8 aB 87:  =8!8O8B= 7!=B =8O:`  Y0. $*+ 53#$ Z '+3.# $*+ 8.()($' 7055+6+ :%F5() D87:E =$3$%$+# N+/(+? \0.c()6 P3.$' *3# F++) 4022(##(0)+& ?($* $*+ $3#c 01 .+/(+?()6 3)& .+?.($()6 $*+ 8.()($' 7055+6+ :%F5() =$3$%$+#J 8*(# ?+55 &04%2+)$+&9 .+35W?0.5& -.0F5+2 01 #$3$%$+# &+1()($(0) 3)& ()$+.-.+$3$(0) () 0.&+. $0 2()(2(V+ $*+ )%2F+. 01 40)15(4$# -0#+# 3 F(6 4*355+)6+J \+ &+4(&+& $0 #$%&' $*+ 402F()3$(0) 01 7^P_ 3)& ;\> :> $+4*)(U%+# () 0.&+. $0 $34c5+ $*+ +)40&()6 01 +,(#$()6 #$3$%$+#9 $*+ &+$+4$(0) 01 40)15(4$# ?*+) +)10.4()6 )+? 3)& +,(#$()6 #$3$%$+#J =02+ 01 $*+ 4*355+)6+# $*(# +110.$ *3#9 (# $0 43-$%.+ $*+ 402-5+,($' 01 $*+ 0.63)(V3$(0)35 #$.%4$%.+ 01 $*+ 7055+6+9 ?($* $*+ -05(4(+# 3)& 0F5(63$(0)# -+.$3()()6 $0 +34* 7055+6+ F0&'J Y0. $*(# -%.-0#+ $*+ %#+ 01 $*+ 7^P_ ?3# 4*0#+) 3# 3 43)&(&3$+ $0 20&+5 -05(4' #%FT+4$#J !5#09 &%+ $0 $*+ .+3#0)()6  -0?+. 01 ;\> :>9 #$3$(4 40)15(4$ 3)35'#(# 40%5& F+ -+.10.2+& 3)& $*(# ?3# 0)+ &.(/()6 134$0. 10. %#()6 0)$0506(+#J a0?+/+.9 $*+ 23() 4*355+)6+ $*3$ ?+ 134+& ?3# 1()&()6 $*+ .(6*$ ,'4'*&"  F+$?++) $*+ %#+ 01 7^P_ 3)& ;\> :> () $+.2# 01 #'#$+2 +,-.+##(/($' ?($*0%$ ()4%..()6 3 F(6 -+)35$' 0) $*+ %#+. &$3*)()N" 4$'1  J =()4+ ($ (# +)/(#36+& $*3$ #%4* 3 #'#$+2 ?0%5& F+ %#+& )0$ 0)5' F' +,-+.$# () -05(4' 23)36+2+)$9 F%$ 35#0 F' &023() +,-+.$# D(J+J +,-+.$# () 53? #-+4(1(43$(0) () $*(# 43#+E9 $*+ 4.+3$(0) 01 +3#' $0 %#+9 4%#$02 $005# $*3$ #%--0.$ $*+#+ +)40&()6# (# 40)#(&+.+& 01 6.+3$ (2-0.$3)4+J Y(/+ 43.+1%55' #+5+4$+& -3.$(4(-3)$# $00c -3.$ () $*+ %#+. $.(359 +34* ?($* 3 #$.0)6 F34c6.0%)& 0) +($*+. -05(4'WF3#+& 23)36+2+)$9 0)$0506(+#9 0. 506(4 -.06.322()6J 8*(# (#  F+43%#+ $*+ %#+.# ?0%5& F+ 3#c+& $0 +)40&+ #$3$%$+# %#()6 #%4* $+4*)(U%+#J 8*+ %#+. $.(35 ()/05/+& 3 $.3()()6 #+##(0) ()$.0&%4()6 355 +)40&()6 2+$*0&#9 +,32-5+# 01 35.+3&' +)40&+& #$3$%$+# 3)& 1()355' $*+ %#+. #$3$%$+# +)40&()6 #+##(0)J 8*+ ?*05+ $.(35 ?3# .+40.&+& 3)& () $*+ +)& $*+ %#+.# ?+.+ 3#c+& $0 1(55 () 3 U%+#$(0))3(.+J !55 %#+.# #$3.$+& ?($* 7^P_9 3)& (1 ($ ?3# )0$ -0##(F5+ $0 +)40&+ ?($* 7^P_9 $*+' 20/+& $0 $*+ )+,$ 3/3(53F5+ +)40&()6 2+$*0&9 ?*(4* (# 7^P_m:>J 8*+ #32+ *3--+)+& %)$(5 $*+ %#+.# $.3/+.#+& 355 .+23()()6 +)40&()6 2+$*0&#9 )32+5' ;\> :>9 ;\> :> m >P9 3)& >PJ 8*+ ;\> :> m >P 2+$*0& ?3# () +##+)4+ $*+ %#+ 01 $*+ =\N> 53)6%36+J \*+) #+5+4$()6 >P () $*(# $.(359 $*+ %#+.# *3& $0 %#+ $*+ #')$3, 01 3 6+)+.(4 .%5+ 53)6%36+ #%4* 3# :.005# QRXSJ  ;.   S#"! (!)'4 $%(&$9" Y(6%.+ R -.0/(&+# 3 402-3.(#0) F+$?++) $*+ &(11+.+)$ +)40&()6 2+$*0&# () $+.2# 01 $*+ +3#(+#$ 2+$*0& $0 %#+9 ?*(4* (# 3) ()&(.+4$ ()&(43$(0) 01 $*+ %#+. 406)($(/+ 503& +,-+.(+)4+&J ;) 3/+.36+9 20#$ %#+.# F+5(+/+ $*3$ 7^P_m:> (# $*+ +3#(+#$ +)40&()6 2+$*0& $0 %#+9 3)& (# 10550?+& F' 7^P_9 ;\> :>9 :>m>P 3)& 1()355' >PJ 7^P_m:> 3)& +#-+4(355' 7^P_ #40.+ 50? () $+.2# 01 +3#+ 01 %#+ 10. $*0#+ %#+.# ?*0 *3/+ F++) +,-0#+& /+.' 5($$5+ 0. )0$ 3$ 355 -.(0. $0 $*+ +,-+.(2+)$ $.3()()6 #+##(0)J ;$*+. 1()&()6# D)0$ #*0?) () Y(6%.+ RE #*0? $*3$ &%+ $0 ($# ()3F(5($' 01 ()1+..()6 40)&($(0)35# ;\> :> (# $*0%6*$ 01 F+()6  $*+ 2+$*0& 5+3#$ #%($+& 10. +)40&()6 #$3$%$+# 3)& 0.63)(V3$(0)35 .%5+# () 6+)+.35J D&+4-, KL )3.&,./ ,*'$9&*+ 7,/0$9 /$ 4., G) 40)$.3#$9 :>m>P (# .+63.&+& 3# $*+ 20#$ #%($+& 2+$*0& 10. +)40&()6 #$3$%$+# 23()5' F+43%#+ 01 ($# 3F(5($' $0 +3#(5' &+#4.(F+ 40)&($(0)35#J :>m>P (# 450#+5' 10550?+& F' 7^P_m:> 23()5' &%+ $0 $*+ 53$$+.<# 3F(5($' $0 $3c+ 3&/3)$36+ 01 $*+ -0?+.1%5 7^P_ 40)#$.%4$# #%4* 3# $*+ e(2-5(+# 3%$*0.($'g .+53$(0)#*(-9 ?*(4* (# 40%-5+& () $*(# 43#+ ?($* $*+ 3F(5($' $0 3&& %#+.W&+1()+& -.0-+.$(+#9 3# ?+55 3# e(#W3g .+53$(0)#*(-#J 7^P_ (# 35#0 1+3$%.+& -.02()+)$5' 3# #%($3F5+ 10. +)40&()6 #$3$%$+#9 F+43%#+ 01 $*+ .+3#0)# &(#4%##+& #0 13.9 3# ?+55 3# &%+ $0 ($# 3F(5($' $0 +,-.+## 40)&($(0)35# /(3 .+#$.(4$()6 2+2F+.#*(- ()$0 7022%)($(+#9 35F+($ #02+$(2+# .+#%5$()6 () 7022%)($(+# $*3$ 3.+ 363()#$ -+0-5+#< ?3' 01 $*()c()6J pJ   : G=7O==G;M  8*+ 23() -%.-0#+ 01 $*(# %#+. $.(35 ?3# $0 $+#$ #+23)$(4355' &(11+.+)$ $+4*)0506(+# #%4* 3# 7022%)($'WF3#+& P05(4' _3)36+2+)$ D7^P_E9 0)$0506(+# 3)& .%5+WF3#+& #'#$+2# () 20&+5()6 .+35 ?0.5& #4+)3.(0#J 8*+ 20&+5()6 01 -05(4' #%FT+4$# %#()6 7^P_ 3)& -05(4' $3.6+$# %#()6 ;\> 40%5& F+  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m:> +)40&()6 2+$*0& 43) F+ #++) 3# 3 F.(&6+ F+$?++) $?0 &(11+.+)$ ?0.5&#J O#()6 7^P_m:> () $*+ $.(35#9 $*+ %#+.# ?+.+ 3F5+ $0 4.+3$+ 4%#$02  -.0-+.$(+# 3)& ()$%($(/+ +)40&()6# () $*+ 43#+# ?*+.+ 7^P_  -.0&%4+& 40%)$+.W()$%($(/+ 0)+#J pGJ   7 ;M7>O=G;M=  8*(# .+#+3.4* 3(2# $0 3##(#$ -05(4' +,-+.$# 3)& &023() +,-+.$# () $*+ $3#c 01 G8 -05(4' +)6()++.()69 3)& +#-+4(355' () -05(4' #-+4(1(43$(0) 3)& () -05(4' 40)15(4$ .+#05%$(0) ?*+) 20&+5()6 .+35 ?0.5& #4+)3.(0#9 ?($* 01$+) 1.+U%+)$ 0.63)(V3$(0)35 3)& G8 .+#0%.4+ 4*3)6+J 8*+ ?0.c #*0?) () $*(# -3-+. 104%#+# 0) 1()&()6 $*+ .(6*$ F353)4+ F+$?++) #+23)$(4355' &(11+.+)$ 20&+5()6 $+4*)(U%+# F0$* () $+.2# 01 +,-.+##(/($'9 3# ?+55 3# () $+.2# 01 $*+ 406)($(/+ 503& +,-+.(+)4+& F' $*+ -05(4' 3%$*0.#J =%4* 3) +/35%3$(0) 43) *+5- &+$+.2()+ #*0.$1355# () $*+ &+#(6) 01 $*+ #01$?3.+ #'#$+2 0. 01 $*+ -05(4' 20&+5 %#+&J 8*(# ?0.c -.0-0#+# 3 2+$*0&0506' F3#+& 0) $*+ *'F.(& ()$+6.3$(0) 01 :+#4.(-$(0) 506(4 D:>E 3)& >06(4 P.06.322()6 D>PE9 ?*(4* %$(5(V+# $*+ 7022%)($'WF3#+& P05(4' _3)36+2+)$ 1.32+?0.c 10. +)40&()6 -05(4' #%FT+4$# 3)& ;\> :> 10. 20&+5()6 -05(4' $3.6+$#J G) +##+)4+9 $*(# 2+$*0& +,$+)&# 7^P_ ?($* ;\> :> -.+&(43$+# 3)& ($ (# 4355+& 7^P_m:>J N+53$+& ?0.c 43) F+ 10%)& () QRZS9 ?*+.+ $*+ 3%$*0.#  -.+#+)$ 3 #+2(W3%$023$(4 ?3' 01 +)40&()6 .+6%53$0.' -05(4(+#  F3#+& 0) -.+W&+1()+& $+2-53$+#J ! 7@M;\>B:C_BM8 8*+ 3%$*0.# ?0%5& 5(c+ $0 34c)0?5+&6+ $*+ 7+)$.+ 10. M+,$ C+)+.3$(0) >0435(#3$(0) D7MC>E D???J4)65J(+E9 10. ($# #%--0.$J N  BYBNBM7B=   QRS @J Y++)+'  +  7J 8#3.0%4*(#9 3)& :J >+?(#9 qP05(4(+# 3# =(6)35# () 70553F0.3$(/+ P05(4' B)6()++.()69q -.+#+)$+& 3$ $*+ P05(4'WF3#+& !%$0)02(4 702-%$()6 \0.c#*0-9 P^!79 XllhJ QXS CJ !)$0)(0%  + "( '4. 9 q702F()()6 N%5+# 3)& ;)$0506(+#J ! #%./+'9q Xll]J QZS YJ ^33&+.   + "( '4. 9 T6" B"#&!):()$* A$3)& U'*1,$$2  9 XllXJ Q[S 7J ^3.35 3)& _J C+510)&9 q >06(4 -.06.322()6 3)& c)0?5+&6+ .+-.+#+)$3$(0)9q  V$%!*'4 $0 A$3)& =!$3!'99)*3+ /05J RkrXl9 --J hZWR[j9 Rkk[J Q]S :J ^3$.39 q706)($(/+ 402-5+,($' () &3$3 20&+5()6d 43%#+# 3)& .+4022+)&3$(0)#9q  H"W%)!"9"*(# X*3)*""!)*3+ /05J /05 RX9 --J XZRWX[[9 XllhJ QbS ^J 8#0%23# 3)& :J C.($V35(#9 q80?3.&# 3) ;)$0506'WF3#+& =+4%.($' _3)36+2+)$9q -.+#+)$+& 3$ $*+ P.04++&()6# 01 $*+ Xl$* G)$+.)3$(0)35 70)1+.+)4+ 0) !&/3)4+& G)10.23$(0) M+$?0.c()6 3)& !--5(43$(0)#9 XllbJ QhS ;\>W0/+./(+?J 6((:YZZ555.5J.$!3ZTHZ$54R0"'(%!"#Z  J QjS =\N>J 6((:YZZ555.5J.$!3ZM%,9)##)$*ZM@HAZ  J QkS :J YJ Y+..3(050 3)& :J NJ @%*)9 qN05+ ^3#+& !44+## 70)$.059q () F[(6 \'()$*'4 8$9:%("! M"&%!)(7 8$*0"!"*&" 9 RkkX9 --J ]][W]bZJ QRlS @J Y++)+'  + "( '4. 9 qN+53$(0)#*(-W:.(/+) P05(4' B)6()++.()6 10. !%$0)02(4 ;.63)(#3$(0)#9q () ](6 KXXX K*("!*'()$*'4 @$!2#6$: $*  =$4)&)"# 0$! B)#(!),%("1 M7#("9# ^=?AK8_ `[G 9 Xll]9 --J --jk W kjJ QRRS NJ ^.+))3)  + "( '4. 9 qP05(4'WF3#+& ()$+6.3$(0) 01 2%5$(-.0/(&+. &(6($35 *02+ #+./(4+#9q  \"(5!2. >'3. $0 a4$,'4 K*("!*"(523.+ /05J XZ9 --J ]lW]b9 XllkJ QRXS :.005#J 6((:YZZ4',#.-,$##.&$9Z1!$$4#Z  J QRZS CJ @05(3&(#  + "( '4. 9 q!)35'#$W_+&(3$+& 70)$+,$%35(V3$(0) 01 N+6%53$0.' P05(4(+#9q -.+#+)$+& 3$ $*+ P.04++&()6# 01 $*+ XlRl GBBB G)$+.)3$(0)35 70)1+.+)4+ 0) =+./(4+# 702-%$()69 XlRlJ  
Search
Similar documents
View more...
Tags
Related Search
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks